Google moves to end EU antitrust probe without fine

Google has formally submitted a package of concessions to European Union competition regulators

By - April 12, 2013 Share on LinkedIn
Google logo dripping

Google has formally submitted a package of concessions to European Union competition regulators in a strong signal that the world’s No. 1 search engine may be able to settle a two-year antitrust investigation without a fine.

Google first offered proposals at the end of January following a spate of complaints from rivals such as Microsoft that triggered the European Commission‘s investigation in November 2010.

But the company, which has a market share of over 80 percent in Europe’s Internet search market according to research firm comScore, has now made a formal offer after fine-tuning its proposals following discussions with the EU antitrust authority.

“In the last few weeks, the Commission completed its preliminary assessment formally setting out its concerns. On this basis, Google then made a formal submission of commitments to the Commission,” said Antoine Colombani, the Commission’s spokesman on competition policy.

“We are now preparing the launch of a market test to seek feedback from market players, including complainants, on these commitment proposals,” he said, declining to provide details.

EU Competition Commissioner Joaquin Almunia, speaking in Washington, said on Thursday that whatever agreement is reached will be legally binding.

“I am trying to reach a decision … that will include legally binding commitments based on the Google proposal,” he told reporters.

The U.S. Federal Trade Commission wrapped up a similar probe in early January by concluding that Google did not manipulate search results.

It also extracted pledges that Google would end the practice of “scraping” content from other websites for its products and allow advertisers to export analytical data, but did not take formal, legal action to ensure those pledges would be met – a decision that angered Google’s critics.

Almunia brushed aside questions about whether the FTC’s conclusions would make it more difficult for his investigators to make a different finding. “This is not creating any difficulty for our investigation,” he said.

He also said that there had been no decision made on whether to investigate complaints by Google critics such as Microsoft that Google was guilty of predatory pricing in offering its Android mobile operating system for free.

“We have not yet decided if a formal investigation will be launched or not,” Almunia said.


People familiar with the matter have previously told Reuters that Google has offered to label its own services in search results to differentiate them from rival services, and also to impose fewer restrictions on advertisers.

Google spokesman Al Verney said the company continues to work cooperatively with the Commission. A settlement with the regulator would stave off a fine that could reach $5 billion, or 10 percent of its 2012 revenues.

The Commission said Google may have violated antitrust rules by pushing its own services over those of rivals, copying travel and restaurant reviews from competing sites without permission and restricting advertisers from moving to competing services.

The market test is critical to determine whether regulators accept Google’s concessions or demand more.

In an indication of the pitfalls still ahead for Google, online German mapping service and Google complainant Hotmaps said the concessions must address rivals’ concerns.

“ will actively partake in the market testing of Google’s concessions and only accept a settlement if competition is fully restored in a future-proof manner,” said Michael Weber, the company’s chief executive.

Frustrated by the slow pace of the Commission’s investigation, rivals such as British price comparison site Foundem, U.S. online sites Expedia and TripAdvisor, and German publishers have already urged tougher action.

British online mapping company Streetmap, another Google complainant in the EU investigation, took its case to the British court on Thursday, citing damage incurred as a result of Google’s practices.

(Additional reporting by Diane Bartz in Washington; Editing by Luke Baker, Clelia Oziel and Jim Marshall)

More business news

Apple, Google won’t face poaching class action suit – yet

Google anti-trust probe ends with mild reprimand

Bitcoins bubble fears

IT salaries in SA: are you underpaid or overpaid?

What should the new Telkom CEO do?

White Gauteng males are highest earners: SAIRR

Share your thoughts

Join the conversation

Connect with Us



Would you buy a Mercedes-Benz bakkie?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

More News

Cheap Microsoft virtual reality headsets announced


Microsoft has stated that hardware partners will bring affordable virtual reality headsets to the market in 2017.

Windows 10 Creators Update announced

Windows 10 logo

Microsoft has announced the next update for Windows 10, the Creators Update.

Government budgets R987 billion for energy, transport, and telecommunications

South Africa Rand Money Notes Coins

National Treasury has budgeted R987.4bn for infrastructure over the next three years, with investments set to be made in energy, transport and telecommunications.

Great at doing awareness campaigns, not so good at actual work

Faith Muthambi

The Department of Communications has exceeded its “digital broadcasting awareness campaigns” target – but has failed to meet multiple digital TV migration deadlines.

Free MyBroadband Newsletter