ICASA and DoC – is there a power struggle?

Does the ministry have a different meaning for the word ‘independent’ than its definition in the new Penguin English dictionary?

September 24, 2012
DoC data pipe bits bytes binary Department of Communication

In August 2012 the Department of Communications (DoC) published the Electronic Communications Amendment (ECA) Bill 2012 with the aim of creating a parallel organisation that will be responsible for the management of the radio spectrum. The Bill proposes a sizeable structure to manage what everyone understood to be the Independent Communications Authority of South Africa (ICASA)’s role. So if the amendments are accepted and the Bill becomes law, more money will have to be allocated to the DoC.

It is ironic that the ministry believes that it can afford to finance the creation of a parallel organisation as it is currently throttling the funds made available to ICASA to do its job. The other question that arises is: “Does the ministry have a different meaning for the word ‘independent’ than its definition in the new Penguin English dictionary: Not affiliated with a larger controlling unit?”

If ICASA was truly an independent agency and was funded correctly, it would be staffed at the right level and with the appropriate expertise. Now when ICASA employees build up experience they are lured away to industry, with more benefits and higher salaries.

At the first African ICT Indaba held in June 2012 the Minister of Communication, Dina Pule announced the establishment of an ICT policy review panel to review and overhaul SA’s ICT policies.

She said, “We want the policies to deliver our progressive goals of achieving universal access to broadband much faster. To this end, we have invited nominees to serve on the ICT policy panel of experts, a group that will work with the department to provide policy recommendations.

Nominations for the panel had to be submitted by 30 June 2012.

Clearly the ICT policy review panel was the minister’s response to wide-ranging criticism of the current policy and the poor handling of frequency spectrum management by ICASA. At the April 2012 Colloquium, industry strongly voiced its opposition to government’s approach.

But if nominations for the panel closed on 30 June, how was it possible for the ministry to gazette the ECA Bill 2012 at the end of July? It could not have been based on input from the panel as its members do not seem to have been appointed yet. If they were, it must have been hush-hush as at the time of publication there was no mention of the names of panel members on the DoC website.

Is DoC trying to beat ICASA to the post? Maybe ICASA had a wake-up call and beat the minister to it! ICASA has put a lot of effort into the 124-page document, it would be a shame if all the work is ignored and the process started all over again by the new spectrum management agency.

Karel Pienaar

Karel Pienaar

MTN CEO, Karel Pienaar, said at the Indaba in June, “Spectrum allocation needs to be done immediately and allocations must not be fragmented. Governments should not try to artificially increase competition through licensing.

“There are many examples in Europe of how this has not worked. Instead, they should facilitate e-skills, planning, and local content support. State-owned enterprises should be encouraged to tender with the private sector for ICT expansion initiatives.”

I believe that the sentiments expressed by Pienaar reflect how the South African communications industry feels about the issue.

Source: EngineerIT

Related articles

ISPA slates ICASA for half-hearted effort

Talk, talk, talk, but no action whatsoever

ADSL regulations: ICASA asking to be ignored?

ADSL regulations mess

ICASA to revisit ADSL regulations, may address ADSL pricing

Tags: DoC, Headline, ICASA, karel pienaar, MTN

Free Email Newsletter:
Subscribe

Shutterstock is the image partner of MyBroadband – technology images can be found here

Join the conversation

Connect with MyBB

twitterfacebookandroidappleblackberrynewsletterfeed

Poll

Which smartphone do you have?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

More News

iPhone versus Samsung: top smartphone battle

Samsung iPhone

Fierce rivalry between iPhone and Samsung widens the gap between the pair and other mobile handset brands

Twitter is “source of all evil and destruction”

Twitter Logo

The microblogging site Twitter popular among both men and women in ultra-conservative Saudi Arabia is nothing more than “a source of lies” and evil, the kingdom’s top Muslim cleric said

DStv-Samsung Android app exclusivity ending soon

DStv BoxOffice

The exclusivity period for MultiChoice’s DStv BoxOffice app with Samsung will be ending soon

Small business department stands by e-tolls

e-toll

The small business development department stood by the national government’s position on e-tolls, while the e-toll advisory panel continued its work, Minister Lindiwe Zulu said on Tuesday

Free MyBroadband Newsletter:
Subscribe
X
bool(true)