PDA

View Full Version : Incorrect billing for GPRS on MTN



titanium
09-08-2005, 09:38 AM
When MTN announced that they were going to drop prices for GPRS from R25/mb to R2/mb commencing from the 11th April, I was really looking forwards to this as I previously had the 2mb GPRS bundle for about R50/month. I received a SMS from MTN a few days before the 11th April informing me that the new billing scheme would take place automatically, and there was no need for user intervention on my part (i.e. my 2mb GPRS bundle would fall away and be replaced by a flat rate of R2/mb). So from the 11th April, I started using GPRS more regularly (mainling for ICQing from my cell).

Well, to cut a long story short:

1. Nashua (my service provider) continued to bill me at 20kb increments at R25/mb.
2. After complaining to them and escalating the issue to Nashua and MTN, they continued to bill me at the incorrect old rate for the next 3 months.
3. Finally, in July, my bill reflected a per byte GPRS counter, i.e. instead of 20kb increments, it showed how many bytes I actually used. However, they still billed me at R25/mb instead of R2/mb.

My GPRS usage is pretty small - about 20mb per month cumulative, according to my Sony Ericsson P900 GPRS counter. So - instead of paying R40/month for GPRS usage, MTN is charging me R500.

I am still sorting out this mess with MTN / Nashua, who have been very lax and unhelpful, and they have come up with all sorts of excuses, such as claiming that they had to find out from the Data Billing department whether using GPRS from my laptop would incur a higher cost than using GPRS from my phone!?! (the answer was no, GPRS costs are uniform regardless of what you use it for - I could have told them that!) I'm hoping to get a final resolution to this issue on Thursday and get a refund for the overbilling - failing which, I'll have to rock the boat a lot more.

So - I don't think I can be the only one experiencing GPRS billing woes. A friend of mine is with M-Tel and they have billed him correctly for his GPRS usage. If you use GPRS, have you checked your billing, and is it correct? To recap - billing should be done at R2 / mb, on a per byte basis, not at R25/mb in 20 kb increments.

Cheers

Goobie
09-08-2005, 09:46 AM
I'm with MTNSP and my billing is spot on. For the first 2 days after the 11th of April I was billed incorrectly, but that was resolved really fast via MTN's people that frequent this forum.

asmith
09-08-2005, 10:39 AM
Sounds like something on NashuaMobile's billing system was not updated for the new rates
Frankly I generaly have had bad service when dealing with any of the service providers other than MTNSP

ebendl
09-08-2005, 10:56 AM
Sounds like something on NashuaMobile's billing system was not updated for the new rates
Frankly I generaly have had bad service when dealing with any of the service providers other than
...the actual Network service provider.

Its the same with other networks as well. Though, generally, I feel that NashuaM is rather horrible in particular. Only my opinion, though.

Scandium
09-08-2005, 12:33 PM
I have a MTN contract through NashuaMobile. Although I don't use the data services extensively this is what had reflected on my most recent statement from NM.

GPRS 521,619 B R0.89

Which seems to be correct.

Incredible
09-08-2005, 01:46 PM
Titanium, I've had a similar experience with Autopage. In brief, i was incorrectly billed for GPRS at R50/mb for all my usage on the 11th April (the 12th onwards was @R2/mb), required by Autopage to prove that the MTN's new billing was effective from the 11th. This took a period of 3 months and when they finally agreed i was correct they incorrectly credited me adding to my frustrations.

I can totally relate to your experience especially from the lack of knowledge from a service providers point of view who often blindly accept any information provided to them from the network (in my case it was that the billing was effective from the 12th and not the 11th - someone in MTN provided them with incorrect info, but since it was from the network it was treated like gospel).

I eventually had to send the a recorded voice conversation from 1555 where the MTN operator states that the billing was effective from the 11th. Info I as a customer acted on.

Anyway, my suggestion: climb as high up as you can. Make sure that you are heard and then negotiate further incentives from your SP as compensation for your inconvenience.

I hunted for the right person and eventually got refunded for all my calls to Autopage, creditted correctly and a few freebies to make me smile again.

Also there are excellent ppl from MTN that use this site and they are extremely helpful and efficient.

sgs
09-08-2005, 05:23 PM
Titanium, what package are you on? The older "discontinued" packages (e.g. packages not actively marketed any more) are all charged at R25/mb, no matter what.

titanium
10-08-2005, 01:26 AM
I was previously on the 2mb GPRS bundle. It was still valid before the new billing scheme kicked in, and I got a SMS from MTN saying that I would default to the new billing scheme automatically.

divv
10-08-2005, 08:18 AM
I was previously on the 2mb GPRS bundle. It was still valid before the new billing scheme kicked in, and I got a SMS from MTN saying that I would default to the new billing scheme automatically.
Hope you kept the sms... Proof!