Are SA’s ADSL and fibre prices really that high?

Is it "fair" to quote cost of those foreign services in Rands and not in locals currency, as applicable?

I wont mind paying 75 of my local currency for a 50meg 100gig service, yet the cheapest i can get locally is the Vox special at 164 of my local smackaroos. But since I'm an Aussie, who earns Aus Dollar, 75 is cheaper than 164 for me.
 
Last edited:
Yes they are that high... even if you work in exchange rate (which you probably shouldn't) it is cheaper overseas, and moreover they don't come with their stupid line rentals like they do here. There is a service fee, but not like the stupidity here. However, I do feel we have the most freedom, and that freedom does come at a price. Try and dabble in torrents in a place like Australia.. see what happens to you...
 
Well, we all know that we are being ripped off, how else can companies like vumatel and 123net offer better deals than telkom.
 
BS article. Yes it is that high. R699 doesn't even compare to R425 on an exchange rate basis let alone a value one. When it comes to value other countries completely blow us out of the water. If you are looking for a high end service then I suppose the situation isn't that bad but it's with the low end entry level ones we are suffering.
 
Yep. That 10mbps looks so good compared to unlimited 76mbps.

I would have thought more factors went in to play, instead of just a straight conversion of Rand value. At least do a R per mbps value rating, not forgetting to include other things like Telkom voice line rental. Why have uncapped and capped on the same list? No comparison between the two other than price (which is incorrectly calculated anyways).
 
local fixed broadband prices are in line with international standards for low-end packages
Click to expand...
Hardly. eg Bottom end fibre package for my place is 50meg that's uncapped after hours for 800 ZAR. The comparable SA packages are double if not triple that. After factoring in that salaries are also higher overseas & the gap becomes even bigger.

* In fairness that 800 bucks thing has a tiny day time cap, so avg mybb user would probably spend 1.3ish

Mt staff writer has also omitted all the countries with cheap fast Internet (S Korea etc).

Nonetheless SA has made some serious progress at least...so getting there.
 
Not to be too pedantic, but that 20mpbs 50GB from Telkom is R799 from 1 August
 
Terrible article. It is just more propaganda, to get us to accept the horrid ADSL offerings in this country, all while trying to make us believe, we are getting a world standard good deal.

We are not... If this article wants to compare apples with apples, bear in mind that the UK has a 60ish million population (close to ours) and they have many people living in outlying areas, where it's hard to get copper exchanges to. Hence the roll out of fibre. But that is where the similarities end.

The political will and push in the UK, have ensured that fibre rollout has been implemented reasonably effectively. Most villages, you can get 20meg to 150 meg connections. Yeeeeeees, it's the same as here regarding contention, but it's more than offset by free landline/cell calling, entertainment packages and reasonable monthly data caps.

And finally, there is the tripe that are exchanges rates, that this article sites as valid proof. Rubbish. This comparison is utterly mauled by the fact that the average monthly family salary in the UK is 2000 to 3000 pounds per month with extra benefits...
I seriously doubt the average South African family, out of our 50ish million population, takes home 40 000 to 60 000 Rand per month, excluding extra benefits.
 
a Lot of these overseas package have extras thrown in which you don't get here as well..
 
What an utterly pointless and shoddy article. This guy spent 20 minutes googling figures and wrote an article on just that. Seriously poor journalism, as if it's an afterthought to fill up space.

Had the writer done the minimal amount of proper effort, taking into account what others have mentioned in this forum so far, it could have passed as something half decent at least! Also, a very poor choice of comparison samples. Comparing SA to USA, UK and AU makes no sense. The more I bother reading news (myBB included) the less I want to - the quality and blatant sensationalism is totally out of control. You have to click through to these forums from the articles to get ACTUAL news from the forum community. *sigh*

Sonic2k does make a good point i.r.o having more freedom though. But I think it's time that asymmetrical starts getting phased out - it's an agonizing hassle getting large files to the cloud or broadcasting live streams at a decent quality. We're forever getting held back while the rest of the world develops economic benefits as the net evolves. Between Telkom and Eskom, it's a miracle there's a growth rate to this economy at all...
 
1 Gb/s uncapped and unshapped
20Go of cloud space
Unlimited phone calls to landlines and mobiles in 120 countries.
Router the size of an Apple TV
You can use your smartphone as TV remote, play on Android games, voice command
Stream on your TV, tablet, smartphone
Catchup service on 27 channels + VOD
163 TV channels included (some additional ones are in option)

For 25.99 euro per month = R360 per month.

https://www.bouyguestelecom.fr/offres-internet/bbox-miami
 
For me the price of bandwidth is fair, it is the line rental that make it difficult to swallow. Telkom allready asked money for the infrastructure that is included in their wholesales prices to ISP, so why not ask fixed fee like R50 for dsl line rental (any speed) and make a higher installation fee to cover the acctual cable an labour.
 
Articles like this is why mybb advertised for a new journalist, someone's gonna get fired
 
Thor187 said:
Articles like this is why mybb advertised for a new journalist, someone's gonna get fired
Click to expand...

Yes, That article has to be some of the worst Journalism on here, absolutely pointless article.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter