Author Salman Rushdie attacked on stage at event in New York

[saturnz]

Your quote says ordering Muslims not Shia Muslims. Does the average fanatic care?

my point stands

I will help you even further, there was nothing binding about that fatwa on anyone

 

[R13...]

my point stands

I will help you even further, there was nothing binding about that fatwa on anyone

Doesn't seem to have mattered to the nut who stabbed him. When a fatwa does bind, how is it enforced and who is expected to carry it out. Easier in the theocracies in the east I guess but outside of a theocracy you'll be arrested. I imagine the fanatics do want to be killed for it.

 

[saturnz]

Doesn't seem to have mattered to the nut who stabbed him.

as you say, its a nut, thats the end of the discussion

out of 1.5bn sunni muslims, it took one (possibly shia) nut to do something 30 years later

if thats not evidence of a fatwa that has no binding then I'm not sure what you consider to be binding

 

[R13...]

as you say, its a nut, thats the end of the discussion

out of 1.5bn sunni muslims, it took one (possibly shia) nut to do something 30 years later

if thats not evidence of a fatwa that has no binding then I'm not sure what you consider to be binding

View attachment 1364243

The binding or not of it doesn't seem to have mattered in this case. The number of attempts on his life makes it clear that some in the faith took the mullah's words to mean it's binding. I'm sure people have been killed on fatwas issues by Al Qaeda and Taliban.

 

[Vrotappel]

There are at least two popular violent religions of peace.

And the relevance of that to this thread?

 

[saturnz]

The binding or not of it doesn't seem to have mattered in this case. The number of attempts on his life makes it clear that some in the faith took the mullah's words to mean it's binding. I'm sure people have been killed on fatwas issues by Al Qaeda and Taliban.

a fatwa is nonbinding...

if like you, nut jobs think it's binding that doesn't change the fact that fatwas are non binding

 

[Vrotappel]

a fatwa is nonbinding...

if like you, nut jobs think it's binding that doesn't change the fact that fatwas are non binding

Most of the religion of peace supporters then seems to be nutjobs.

 

[saturnz]

On 14 February 1989, Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini, the Supreme Leader of Iran and one of the most prominent Shi'a Muslim leaders, issued a fatwa calling for the death of Rushdie and his publishers.


Whats that word.
For lying to people, if it suits the religion.
There are two religions that i know of that allow it.

Your ignorance is showing strongly in that post. Keep going

 

[Defonotaltaccount]

Taq.....

 

[saturnz]

Most of the religion of peace supporters then seems to be nutjobs.

still doesn't change the fact that a fatwa is non binding

 

[Cray]

So go ahead and use another famous religious figure.
Like the one in the religion in the article mentioned.
Cmon lets see if you would do it then.
Bet you wont.

Last I checked, shouting "Mohammad" at something outrageous didn't mean too much, but if it makes you feel better... Mohammed, Allah...!

Now... FO!

 

[Defonotaltaccount]

Last I checked, shouting "Mohammad" at something outrageous didn't mean too much, but if it makes you feel better... Mohammed, Allah...!

Now... FO!

Thanks hon.
You will be pleased to note that you evaded.

 

[Cray]

Thanks hon.
You will be pleased to note that you evaded.

Tell me what I evaded and I'll front up to it, otherwise begone troll.

 

[Cray]

You used a blasphemous term in relation to Christians.
And praised the other.

Quote my post where I praised the other...

 

[airborne]

also it was a shia that gave the fatwa

so apparently fatwas issued by shia are binding on sunni muslims if we go by the premises of what has already been stated about fatwas in this thread.

Satanic Verses controversy - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

Interesting, I didn't know it was a shia fatwa, I'm assuming sunni's(the majority/largest muslim sect) would just ignore it because most of them seem to look upon shia as if they are dirt?

 

[Neptuner]

This is some John Wick excommunicado fatwa that was given. He sure lasted long seeing that 1.5 billion people were contracted to assassinate him and still going. Maybe the Pope can assist?

 

[Thor]

Sanction the fck out of Iran.

They caused his death.

 

[Thor]

A reminder the sort of thing that led to this, and Cat Stevens is Western educated, vile

Should charge Cat with murder.

 

[Cray]

Should charge Cat with murder.

Rushdie isn't dead mate..

 

[Thor]

School shooters and mass shooters in the US that livestream and post manifestos about it disagree with you

Drop in the ocean