Bring back South African skills - Sir Mick Davis to Andre de Ruyter

RonSwanson

Honorary Master
Joined
May 21, 2018
Messages
15,328
Definitely - so, not an art.

It's a Discipline, in which lots of experience helps.

Given our current workforce debacles, I think management would probably be happy to have literate employee's that aren't actually actively sabotaging the plant.
If Eskom consisted of one power station, and we were only focussing on the technical part, then true.

Eskom's scope is huge, generation, transmission and distribution. Diverse (and largely outdated) generation technologies, with a few newer ones in the mix, it needs very careful management of staff and skill levels, plenty of interesting dynamics, the younger ones don't want to work on the older tech. So how to create and maintain a motivated workforce, and please unions. Then on the finance side there is the demands of NERSA, the PFMA, bonds to finance new capacity, government interference and the demands of government legislation -- AA, BEE. prescriptive procurement policies, thievery, stealing and corruption. And then the pressures from the environmentalists, the Gretas of the world. Add to that the consequences of extremely poor decisions in the past, a bloated inexperienced and useless workforce, billions in debt and poor generation fleet maintenance. It's a whole lot more than just the technical side, that's the easy part.

Pulling all of that together and plotting the right way forward would be an art form, he did refer to a "Power System", and his comment is true for any large, bloated and diverse company that has been decimated by Marxism.
 

Lupus

Honorary Master
Joined
Apr 25, 2006
Messages
50,982
Running a power system is an art, not a science. It needs a huge amount of skill base. It needs people with experience,” Davis said.

Bollocks. It's a science. There are steps, procedures, planning and checks to be done in running a power station. It is not an art in any way whatsoever.
Actually being in a specialised environment there are certain things having knowledge doesn't trump experience, being able to look at something and go hmm this is going to cause a problem in a bit is more of an art then a science. You just begin to learn how certain systems work and the nuances in logs, hell even in noises the systems make.
 

itareanlnotani

Executive Member
Joined
Sep 14, 2008
Messages
6,767
If Eskom consisted of one power station, and we were only focussing on the technical part, then true.

Eskom's scope is huge, generation, transmission and distribution. Diverse (and largely outdated) generation technologies, with a few newer ones in the mix, it needs very careful management of staff and skill levels, plenty of interesting dynamics, the younger ones don't want to work on the older tech. So how to create and maintain a motivated workforce, and please unions. Then on the finance side there is the demands of NERSA, the PFMA, bonds to finance new capacity, government interference and the demands of government legislation -- AA, BEE. prescriptive procurement policies, thievery, stealing and corruption. And then the pressures from the environmentalists, the Gretas of the world. Add to that the consequences of extremely poor decisions in the past, a bloated inexperienced and useless workforce, billions in debt and poor generation fleet maintenance. It's a whole lot more than just the technical side, that's the easy part.

Pulling all of that together and plotting the right way forward would be an art form, he did refer to a "Power System", and his comment is true for any large, bloated and diverse company that has been decimated by Marxism.
Nepotism.

FTFY.
 

The_MAC

Executive Member
Joined
Oct 11, 2012
Messages
8,204
How exactly are they going to explain this to the unions?

Sorry guys, your people are not good enough..
 

mpdjhb

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 11, 2014
Messages
545
The ANC pushed them out to meet quotas - they won't be coming back. Even if they are not all retired already.
This is exactly what happened in Zim too - kick out certain demographics, find out way too late that the people left have no skills and then try and get back the people you tossed to the curb.... (and to be clear that is not because certain people are too stupid etc, it's just that you need apprenticeships under experienced people and experience gained yourself over time to get those skills - there is no short cutting "on the job experience")
 

PaulMurkin

Expert Member
Joined
Jan 31, 2020
Messages
3,455
Running a power system is an art, not a science. It needs a huge amount of skill base. It needs people with experience,” Davis said.

Bollocks. It's a science. There are steps, procedures, planning and checks to be done in running a power station. It is not an art in any way whatsoever.
All of this was known by 1944 already, its not an art... its standard textbook engineering
 

PaulMurkin

Expert Member
Joined
Jan 31, 2020
Messages
3,455
It won't. My brother was an Eskom employee. Emigrated to Aus many years ago. One of the service providers around Eskom tried to get him to come back. Negotiations stalled when they could only match his Aus salary, which on its own wasn't enough enticement to stop building a life in a first world country
I have a friend who works at Orion in New Zealand... Eskom has tried 3 times to get him to come back to Megawatt park. He tells me it gives him such joy to tell them to go fvck themselves every single time.
They retrenched him to make space for an ANC cadre, one of Zuma's family.
 

Herr der Verboten

Honorary Master
Joined
Feb 14, 2012
Messages
22,535
De Ruyter must bring back South African skills — Former Eskom finance chief

Eskom should bring old skills back from overseas to help train the technicians looking after power plants now, according to former Eskom financial chief Mick Davis.

Davis was reportedly blocked from becoming Eskom CEO by the ANC in 1994. He is now a British politician, was awarded the rank of Knight Bachelor, and works in government.
So why isn't he singling out the ANC and its racial policies? or is it easier to talk about eskom or its current head avoiding the obvious?
 

TheChamp

Honorary Master
Joined
Feb 26, 2011
Messages
57,360
You guys should check that the stories don't become too legendary too fast, pace yourself, we still have the whole December ahead of us.
 

PaulMurkin

Expert Member
Joined
Jan 31, 2020
Messages
3,455
You guys should check that the stories don't become too legendary too fast, pace yourself, we still have the whole December ahead of us.
True that, but I am planning to take a break from online activity over December so maybe I should indulge now?
 

Takkies

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 2, 2008
Messages
428
With BEE in place, this is IMPOSSIBLE.
I don't believe they would come back.
The previous skilled staff, hate Eskom.
 
Top