Call for annual roadworthiness tests to be made compulsory in South Africa

Daniel Puchert

Journalist
Staff member
Joined
Mar 6, 2024
Messages
2,412
Reaction score
2,229
Big change proposed for car licence discs in South Africa

Automobile Association CEO Bobby Ramagwede is calling for annual roadworthiness tests to be made compulsory in South Africa, adding that it should be made a requirement for renewing a vehicle licence disc.

Speaking to Newzroom Afrika, Ramagwede explained that pushing the message of improving driver behaviour isn't enough to address road fatalities in the country.
 
The 'annual roadworthy test' should then be based on the one used in the UK, which seems to work quite effectively over there - no MOT renewal once it has expired, your car is deemed as unroadworthy and has to be parked up until such time as it is redone & the vehicle successfully passes the MOT test again...
 
Only if they apply it to everyone across the board, no use in me doing it yearly and then seeing taxis in their current state doing whatever they want
 
Money making excuse. The vast majority of accidents are due to human behaviour*, which this will not address at all. The ONLY real solution is strict constant moving violation enforcement with severe penalties.

*if anyone wants to dispute, you'd better have some stats.
 
I'd be all for it, not every year, but maybe every 2 years for vehicles older than 5 years, or something like that.

If they actually do it properly it will be a big improvement for road safety. I'd say more than half the country's vehicles will probably be taken off the road. The amount of wrecked 1980's junk, held together with tape and wire that I see on the road is staggering.

But of course it won't be done properly. It will be a bribe generation machine.
 
I think best way to fix and have our road and vehicle issues shake out ok over a period is:

pay your car license, get given a crossbow. with 3 bolts. Every subsequent license paid earns 3 bolts, an infringement costs a bolt.

Stiek Uit TAXI, Stiek Uit!!!!
 
A debateable topic is whether should it be applied to new cars, id say < 2yo
What happens if your 'new car' that's LESS than 2 years old is involved in a crash / accident & has had to be rebuilt again?

There are separate insurance categories for vehicle re-registration in the UK that are then applicable for those rebuilds - depending on whether it is minor or major damage, or if the vehicle was written off but rebuilt.

UK Write-Off Categories Explained: Category A, B, N, and S Cars​

Why are cars written off?

An insurer will write off a vehicle if it can’t be repaired to roadworthy condition – either because the damage is too severe, or the cost of repairs outweigh what the car is worth.

If a car is written off, it’ll be assigned to one of the four UK vehicle write-off categories. What happens to the car depends on which category it’s assigned to.

What are the UK write-off categories? Here are the four UK write-off categories, and what they mean for your vehicle if it’s assigned to them:

Category N: Non-Structural Damage

Category N means the car has sustained non-structural damage, and the insurer has decided that repair isn’t economical.

‘Non-structural damage’ could apply to anything from dents or scrapes on cosmetic panels, to mechanical damage affecting integral components. Cars assigned to Category N can usually be repaired with the right parts, but it might cost more than the vehicle’s market value.

Category S: Structural Damage

Category S means the car has sustained structural damage, and the insurer has decided that repair isn’t economical.

This usually means the main chassis or framework have been damaged, and the car would require extensive repairs for it to be roadworthy. However, Category S cars can often still be repaired with the right methods, but the cost of these repairs may exceed what the car is worth.

Category B: Beyond Repair

Any category B write-off means the car has been damaged beyond repair. The car can’t be returned to roadworthy condition, and can’t be re-registered for on-road use.

The car will be sent for salvage by a licensed agent, who will reclaim any reusable parts (like mirrors, intact glass, and panels) before the shell is crushed. These parts can be recycled, and used by repairers as a sustainable alternative to new components.

Category A: Beyond Salvage

Category A means the vehicle and all of its components are beyond salvage. The damage is too extensive to safely remove/reuse any parts – so the shell, all parts and components must be crushed.

The car will be sent to a licensed professional, who will ensure the shell and all of components are safely disposed of. Many of the metals and plastics used in cars can be recycled through industrial processing, and turned into raw materials for use in future products.

Which category means ‘beyond economical repair’?

If a car is deemed ‘beyond economical repair’ (usually meaning the cost of its repair would outweigh its market value) it will either be assigned to category N or S, depending on whether the damage is structural (S), or non-structural (N).

 
Wow. The lost productive time will cost the economy BILLIONS.

If roadblocks actually were planned and operated to also check road worthiness and not just for revenue generation this will be sorted quickly and easily.

Going to the traffic department every year? Are you okes nuts? I already think the drivers license process is crazy.
 
Principle is good. Get the rubbish of the road. Reality is not. absolute no way they can test. The testing stations is already full with car being bought. how will they cater for this flood?
 
Lol, the implementation of this would be a disaster, and as if the taxi bosses would agree to something like this!
 
Too lazy to write tickets for broken lights, so now they want people to come to them instead.
How many days leave will be required to get it done?
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter