OrbitalDawn
Ulysses Everett McGill
- Joined
- Aug 26, 2011
- Messages
- 47,031
Israel has 80% of the land so of course they do.Had a single secular state called Palestine been formed they would have still been Palestinians and living in Palestine.
Why do you think this would have worked in the context of the time?
falcon786 said:Turns out that's just what they did after all.Cauldron has been boiling ever since.
"They" didn't do it, the Arab countries who chose war instead of nation building did.
falcon786 said:How many indigenous Jews were there at the time and how many indigenous Non Jews?How much land was owned by each?
I'm not sure, but for example the city of Tel Aviv was formed on the back of existing communities in the region, such as Jaffa, which is bloody ancient. Old Yishuv refers to the Jewish communities who lived in the region. Long and deep history there.
Seems the Jewish National Fund owned about 4% of Palestine by 1948, which was about 54% of land owned by Jews, which is a miniscule amount.
I also notice how, during the British Mandate, it was illegal to transfer land except to Arab Palestinians.
falcon786 said:Isis wants to create a Caliphate,Jews were living peacefully under the caliphate in the area according your own statement just a few posts earlier.
Yeah, and? They're Arabs who want to boot out indigenous people and create their own country. And the 1 million Jews who were booted out of their homes by Arabs is another example of your question.
And I didn't say they were living peacefully. I said they, in fact, were not peaceful any more as nationalism was a growing trend of the time in the area.
falcon786 said:So are they given equal rights in every respect like citizens should be given?
Yep. Israeli citizens get full rights, non-citizens don't, as in every country on earth.
There are tensions and cases of discrimination, obviously, as there are anywhere, including in SA. But again, for some perspective - look how Jews are treated in all the countries around them, and I refer again to the mass expulsion and persecution of Jews that took place in that time.
There are Arabs in the Knesset, on the Israeli Cabinet, Generals in the Israeli Army, leading academics, and there are Arab judges on the Supreme Court.


