Dis-Chem not allowed to hire anymore white people for now

wingnut771

Honorary Master
Joined
Feb 15, 2011
Messages
28,146
I disagree. I think the biggest downfall of SA is the lack of proper education from primary all through to tertiary education. If people were properly educated and qualified the economic effects of BEE and AA would be insignificant. The ANC has made a lot of mistakes but the biggest, imo, is not focusing large amounts of money and resources on educating the population of this country properly.
They already have been spending vasts amount of money. Ironically, because of BEE and AA the quality ain't so great.
 
Last edited:

wingnut771

Honorary Master
Joined
Feb 15, 2011
Messages
28,146
Maybe, but I don't think there was a real lack of qualified non white people. Cadre deployment, corruption and incompetence in the ANC happens with or without BEE
or they can just leave politics and ideology out of education and let all colours educate. From day 1 of the new south africa they wanted the white teachers out. The same whites that ended apartheid.
 
Last edited:

TheChamp

Honorary Master
Joined
Feb 26, 2011
Messages
57,360
Yes of course not, but looking at the state of our education, I doubt educators and administrators was appointed based on ability.
Let's not pretend like we have stable homes that produces children who are model learners for the teachers, I am super impressed with what our teachers are achieving knowing what they have to deal with.

Honestly trying to confine the state of our education to teachers and administrators is very flawed, we have a societal problem that becomes prevalent at school, putting the blame on teachers and questioning their competence is hugely simplifying the problem.
 

RonSwanson

Honorary Master
Joined
May 21, 2018
Messages
15,327
Yes of course not, but looking at the state of our education, I doubt educators and administrators was appointed based on ability.
They were appointed based on the union's requirements, and the willingness to shag the appointers.
 

BBSA

Honorary Master
Joined
Jul 11, 2005
Messages
21,905
Let's not pretend like we have stable homes that produces children who are model learners for the teachers, I am super impressed with what our teachers are achieving knowing what they have to deal with.

Honestly trying to confine the state of our education to teachers and administrators is very flawed, we have a societal problem that becomes prevalent at school, putting the blame on teachers and questioning their competence is hugely simplifying the problem.
Yes, there are many contributing factors...

But you are delusional if you think all educators and administrators were appointed solely on ability.

We can not redress the mistakes of the past with exactly the same mistakes.
 

Fulcrum29

Honorary Master
Joined
Jun 25, 2010
Messages
55,058

As far as I am concerned, that letter by the CEO of Dischem was racial and devisive. Racial qoutus contributed to our current economic woes. Hire South Africans on Merit, and focus on investment in training where you experience weaknesses.

I see Mighti Jamie replied with this,


Jamie says to look at the general trend, but who established this trend and what IF data is manipulated to drive policy?

Unless people are in the view to take the demographics, group the race classes, and say these are the targets. Oh, wait... quotas. We can’t possibly look at race alone to carry out redress, and yes, there is employment equity, but that is also ignoring circumstance. There is no easy solution to this, but the current method is alienating people, start-ups and small businesses which is swept away by arguing economic reasons.

There are minority groups in SA shrinking, why are they shrinking, what is the general trend, Jamie?

Lastly, how Mashaba replied. Merit isn't key to success in any business, you need suitable candidates in which merit is a metric. Not going into this.
 

wingnut771

Honorary Master
Joined
Feb 15, 2011
Messages
28,146
Let's not pretend like we have stable homes that produces children who are model learners for the teachers, I am super impressed with what our teachers are achieving knowing what they have to deal with.

Honestly trying to confine the state of our education to teachers and administrators is very flawed, we have a societal problem that becomes prevalent at school, putting the blame on teachers and questioning their competence is hugely simplifying the problem.
Started when the ANC banned corporal punishment.
 

TheChamp

Honorary Master
Joined
Feb 26, 2011
Messages
57,360
Yes, there are many contributing factors...

But you are delusional if you think all educators and administrators were appointed solely on ability.

We can not redress the mistakes of the past with exactly the same mistakes.
Well, I believe that most of the educators have the necessary qualifications for the job they were appointed for, that on its own implies they are competent on carrying out the task of being an educator. We can speculate all we want on whether there were other factors that ensured the got the job over others, that's won't be very useful.

Perhaps if you could produce the stats that proves first that there are so many teachers who are in positions they are not qualified for therefore our education is suffering as a result, then that would be a good point to start from.

I believe there are always influences in how people are appointed, either the people who are authorized to influence the process such as those who are in charge of the appointment process, you can argue that unions or so and so also indirectly influence the process, but does it then follow that the person appointed isn't competent?

That's like arguing that someone who was headhunted or recommended for employment is not competent merely because on the fact that he was recommended or headhunted.
 

ijacobs3

Expert Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2009
Messages
4,139
Started when the ANC banned corporal punishment.
couldnt agree more, went to my old school, now ( noCP) vs then, kids just spit at teachers, and there is nothing the teachers can do to install some form of respect, todays young "leaders" are 100% a product of this, there is no fear of consequence for wrong doing, its always someone else fault
 

BBSA

Honorary Master
Joined
Jul 11, 2005
Messages
21,905
Well, I believe that most of the educators have the necessary qualifications for the job they were appointed for, that on its own implies they are competent on carrying out the task of being an educator. We can speculate all we want on whether there were other factors that ensured the got the job over others, that's won't be very useful.

Perhaps if you could produce the stats that proves first that there are so many teachers who are in positions they are not qualified for therefore our education is suffering as a result, then that would be a good point to start from.

I believe there are always influences in how people are appointed, either the people who are authorized to influence the process such as those who are in charge of the appointment process, you can argue that unions or so and so also indirectly influence the process, but does it then follow that the person appointed isn't competent?

That's like arguing that someone who was headhunted or recommended for employment is not competent merely because on the fact that he was recommended or headhunted.
Okay comrade
 
Top