Both things can be true. Liverpool was humiliated, and there's no sense in talking about what might have been 4-3 or 3-4, because it wasn't. If anything, we're the champions of what if this season. Okay, maybe runners up, but as i said, you can be humiliated, and you could honestly not care, i wouldn't.
Because exactly as you've said. I've enjoyed our goal difference title wins as much as "record" point/game title wins with x games to spare. They all feel good, the close ones maybe more, because of the feeling right at the end, compared to the going up 3 0 at half time and knowing you'll close out the game.
The fact that anyone would takes this banter seriously as a liverpool fan, actually says more about them as liverpool fans.