Think you are missing a huge point here.
It’s not a phone at all, but actually a very sorted offering for the correct purpose.
We have 300 odd Chromebooks operating daily in the wild. Excellent managed devices with little to no hassles.
And it can do plenty without internet, but things are only really useful with internet in the modern world anyway so I don’t understand how this is of any concern.
My phone also works perfectly fine without internet, so I actually have no idea what you are on about there.
All I'm saying is that a device like a phone is useless without an Internet connection.
AFAIK Chromebooks are designed for cloud access only? I've never worked on one personally.
Let me put the phone comparison in context. I have one app, which is an offline game on my phone.
Every other app I use on my phone can't do anything without being online.
Sure, if you have a cellular connection you can still phone and text. Let's say you don't have a contract phone or data bundle, how will I make full use of it?
My PC with Windows is completely different. I can use any app or program that is installed without the need to be online. Games, Office, Graphics and Photo editors. Local development tools and the list goes on.
Can a Chromebook work in a similar way?