Google says it’ll ‘work constructively’ with SA competition authorities that want search changes

rvZA

Honorary Master
Joined
Jan 3, 2021
Messages
16,596
Google says it will "work constructively" with South Africa's Competition Commission – albeit to "answer their questions", rather than make changes to how it presents search results in South Africa.

The Competition Commission this week released preliminary findings in a massive, long-running inquiry into the state of competition online, covering everything from property sales to food delivery.

Concerned about the ability of small businesses and black companies to compete online, that inquiry gave Google specific design instructions on how it should present search results, and raised the idea of demanding changes to Android smartphones.

In response, Google has stressed that it is good for competition, and faces competition.

"Our products increase choice and expand competition," the company said in a statement. "They level the playing field for small businesses everywhere — enabling them to sell their products, find customers, reduce their costs and, in difficult times, get back on their feet. The competition Google faces is always increasing: there are more ways than ever that people can find information, from specialized sites for travel and shopping, or from other search engines, social media and elsewhere."

It made no mention of a legal challenge if the report is made final in its current form, an option Business Insider South Africa understands other internet players are exploring.

The Commission wants Google to downgrade the position it gives to paid advertising in search results, a line of business worth more than $13 billion per month globally, or – but most likely, it says, also – better distinguish between ads and organic search by way of design elements such as shading and borders.

 

rvZA

Honorary Master
Joined
Jan 3, 2021
Messages
16,596
Concerned about the ability of small businesses and black companies to compete online, that inquiry gave Google specific design instructions on how it should present search results, and raised the idea of demanding changes to Android smartphones.

Jesus! These guys!

The Commission wants Google to downgrade the position it gives to paid advertising in search results, a line of business worth more than $13 billion per month globally, or – but most likely, it says, also – better distinguish between ads and organic search by way of design elements such as shading and borders.

Do this and I will cancel my Google Adwords and advertise on Twitter and Facebook only.

Concerned with the dominance of Google search, the inquiry also recommend an "end to the default arrangements for Google Search on iOS and Android devices sold in South Africa".

That would potentially require the special reconfiguration of just about every smartphone sold in South Africa.

Easy. I will just import a foreign device or buy one once a year when abroad.
 

Acid0

Executive Member
Joined
Feb 10, 2009
Messages
5,262
I think its easier to upload your struggle / BEE credentials and based on that you need to be bumped up or down on the search engine
 

ForceFate

Honorary Master
Joined
May 18, 2009
Messages
41,141
What the Competition Commission is doing isn't different from what the EU is doing with their antitrust cases.
 

Grant

Honorary Master
Joined
Mar 27, 2007
Messages
60,621
Do this and I will cancel my Google Adwords and advertise on Twitter and Facebook only.
Do it.
Teach those fukkers at Google a lesson they'll never forget.!
 

Fulcrum29

Honorary Master
Joined
Jun 25, 2010
Messages
55,064
Do it.
Teach those fukkers at Google a lesson they'll never forget.!

To be honest, I wouldn't want to pay Google to promote my business only to have my ad downgraded. Most website owners don’t optimise their SEO to actually compete online, and that onus is on the webmasters and not on any search engine.
 

Fulcrum29

Honorary Master
Joined
Jun 25, 2010
Messages
55,064
Essentially, the Competition Commission wants paid ads to be at the bottom, and more so expressed as such.

9f9d4bd1ebc04037a9a78ed5f7f9baae.jpg


Advertisers will simply stop to promote their websites with Google. Then it is all up to SEO... a mechanism I am sure the Competition Commission won't understand which they will likely also scrutinise. I do SEO research every day, and I can say that it isn't given much to any attention here. SEO is hard work.

This is what the Competition Commission stated,


Across all platforms there is a tendency to sell top ranking search positions to businesses which are not the most relevant to the consumer and constitute a form of advertising that is not transparent. This impacts on consumer choice and competition, especially for SMEs that cannot spend as much as large businesses. The Inquiry recommends that advertising is clearly displayed as such and the top results are reserved for organic (or natural) search results.

but now the Competition Commission needs to understand that those top results need to compete. Organic terms, cornerstones and keywords, as well as the correct labelling to better understand the content structure are in the plenitude. The only way to compete with optimised content is to place a search ad. In the ad structures there are relevancy mechanisms to better target your audience.

Large businesses will simply contract businesses who do SEO to drown the competition. Small businesses can do it too, but you need to be invested in it, which most aren't. The market is competitive, and will always be.

I simply think that the Competition Commission is incorrectly approaching this challenge. What Google needs is competition, and yes, it won't be easy, but perhaps the Competition Commission should explore a business directory which is best promoted within our online landscape, having it endorsed and so. I have long said that consortiums are a solution in SA as long as everyone plays the ball.
 

konfab

Honorary Master
Joined
Jun 23, 2008
Messages
36,120
Concerned about the ability of small businesses and black companies to compete online, that inquiry gave Google specific design instructions on how it should present search results, and raised the idea of demanding changes to Android smartphones.

MY FATHER WAS CALLED A GARDEN BOY AND MY MOTHER WAS CALLED A KITCHEN GIRL, THAT IS WHY IT IS RACIST FOR ADVERTS TO BE SHOWN IN GOOGLE.
 

NarrowBandFtw

Honorary Master
Joined
Feb 1, 2008
Messages
27,727
MY FATHER WAS CALLED A GARDEN BOY AND MY MOTHER WAS CALLED A KITCHEN GIRL, THAT IS WHY IT IS RACIST FOR ADVERTS TO BE SHOWN IN GOOGLE.
aye, but you lived in the cold water ... just imagine you had a search engine that could tell you where to buy some towels to dry off with and a blanket to warm up in ...

oh sorry my bad, that's the colonial way, I've decolonized the sentence below just like Google Azania would work:
just imagine you had a search engine that could tell you where to buy get free handouts of some towels to dry off with and a blanket to warm up in

Google Azania will also rework the "I'm Feeling Lucky" button to automatically award you the most lucrative guavamint tenda that matches your search description
 
Top