Household insurance

dazzazzad

Expert Member
Joined
Dec 14, 2006
Messages
1,015
So a couple weeks ago my cottage was broken into (while I slept, thankfully behind a trellidor) and they took my TV, new PC, monitor, winter coat, two pairs of shoes, ipod, laptop etc etc.

Now the cottage is joined to the main house where my folks stay. The building looks like one residence from the outside but there is no interleading door between the two, just a window looking onto a courtyard that's in the middle of the building.

My dad used to be with a broker that took care of everything so my dad never paid too much attention to the details. 5 years ago we had to switch and are now with Santam and a new broker.

When Santam got back to me they said they are restricted to 2% of the total coverage because the cottage is considered an out building. Even though I live there and it's bigger than most apartments.

So instead of the 35k which it'd cost to replace my items, they can only pay 12k. Which is the final groin punch to an already devastating situation.

So it seems Santam just followed policy. And it's certainly on us for not knowing this stuff as well. But am I right to be really pissed off with the broker? My dad says he asks her to come visit like our old broker used to, at the end of every year but she always puts it off and just encourages my dad to sign.

If 12k is 2% of what the main house is covered for, regarding household contents, that is a huge mistake. My folks have a very modest amount of stuff. A fridge that's 5 years old, an ipad 1, an iphone, a 32" lcd that cost 3.5k, no jewelry or expensive clothes. I'm sure 50k coverage would be able to replace anything that robbers could take that doesn't involve a moving van.

And my cottage is also probably at (or rather was) around 50k for all household items, and that's actually pushing it.

Surely she would have seen this in 5 minutes if she had made the effort, unless I'm misunderstanding something here.

Has she been negligent or is it entirely on our shoulders? And if she has been...I guess there's nothing to do but find a new broker and this time make sure all our ducks are in a row?
 

LazyLion

King of de Jungle
Joined
Mar 17, 2005
Messages
105,605
What does this have to do with Current Affairs? Do you have a link for us to the News Article?
 

ToxicBunny

Oi! Leave me out of this...
Joined
Apr 8, 2006
Messages
113,630
Its your policy, so its on you for being over or underinsured...

But if your dad asks for a certain service, and she doesn't provide.. then find a new broker.

Where abouts are you based?
 

dazzazzad

Expert Member
Joined
Dec 14, 2006
Messages
1,015
Its your policy, so its on you for being over or underinsured...

But if your dad asks for a certain service, and she doesn't provide.. then find a new broker.

Where abouts are you based?

Cape Town Southern Suburbs
 

dazzazzad

Expert Member
Joined
Dec 14, 2006
Messages
1,015
Just really dug into things and yeah, my dad is not just overinsured he's OBSCENELY overinsured. I think his iphone is probably the most valuable household item and after that maybe the fridge. To be covered for 600k is ridiculous. So overinsured by a mile and then because they constitute my cottage as an out building we get a claim that is undervalued by a mile.

Well, this is a valuable lesson for sure. This broker is taking advantage of my dad. Bloody highway robbery.
 

ToxicBunny

Oi! Leave me out of this...
Joined
Apr 8, 2006
Messages
113,630
Just really dug into things and yeah, my dad is not just overinsured he's OBSCENELY overinsured. I think his iphone is probably the most valuable household item and after that maybe the fridge. To be covered for 600k is ridiculous. So overinsured by a mile and then because they constitute my cottage as an out building we get a claim that is undervalued by a mile.

Well, this is a valuable lesson for sure. This broker is taking advantage of my dad. Bloody highway robbery.

I'm still intrigued by this "cottage" being an outbuilding. It should make no difference, the insurance is on all items on the property in my opinion.

As for this being massively overinsured, there is only one solution, tell the broker off and get a new one. No questions.
 

ChilliGirl

PopCornPeddler
Joined
Aug 28, 2009
Messages
34,747
I'm still intrigued by this "cottage" being an outbuilding. It should make no difference, the insurance is on all items on the property in my opinion.

As for this being massively overinsured, there is only one solution, tell the broker off and get a new one. No questions.
Yip.

From all that was mentioned it seems like they are being milked by a greedy, lazy broker....
 

Willie Trombone

Honorary Master
Joined
Jul 18, 2008
Messages
60,038
Its about time we made these insurance companies work for their money and assess our properties annually
 

RaymondB

Well-Known Member
Joined
Nov 1, 2007
Messages
174
Two dangerous statements in the OP's first post.

1. "My folks have a very modest amount of stuff. A fridge that's 5 years old, an ipad 1, an iphone, a 32" lcd that cost 3.5k, no jewelry or expensive clothes." Cover is usually based on the replacement value of the household goods

2. "I'm sure 50k coverage would be able to replace anything that robbers could take that doesn't involve a moving van." It is not only theft that is insured, but also Fire and Storm amongst other perils. The value must represent the full replacement value.

Having said all that, I would take it up with your broker who should have ensured that the cover was correctly in place. If you get no joy, then take it up with the Ombudsman for Short-Term Insurance - http://www.osti.co.za
 
Top