How to decide between job offers?

Jet-Fighter7700

Honorary Master
Joined
Mar 12, 2008
Messages
31,618
Hi all,

So I'm in the extremely fortunate position of having more than one job offer presented at one time,
Guess my anti nazi stance did the trick

How would one decide? Money? Distance to travel? Manager?
Or more abstract means? Like more knowledge gain or more stability
Or even change of scenery from office based cubicle , To road warrior driving between many restaurants and franchises but get paid less.

I'm sure many people here have been presented with more than 1 offer at a time, lessons learned? Or clear winner here?
 

Chevron

Serial breaker of phones
Joined
Oct 2, 2007
Messages
25,900
Hi all,

So I'm in the extremely fortunate position of having more than one job offer presented at one time,
Guess my anti nazi stance did the trick

How would one decide? Money? Distance to travel? Manager?
Or more abstract means? Like more knowledge gain or more stability
Or even change of scenery from office based cubicle , To road warrior driving between many restaurants and franchises but get paid less.

I'm sure many people here have been presented with more than 1 offer at a time, lessons learned? Or clear winner here?

Life stage matters.

When younger experience matters more, when older remuneration matters more. (You need to learn to earn).

Then distance travelling/traffic can also depend on whether you have a family or not. If you're a bachelor time in traffic matters a lot less than if you had a family at home waiting for you.

Then there's company culture. Are you the 9-5 type person counting the seconds till you can leave, or is the company the type of place where you can go for beers with work colleagues after work.

Then there's also how interesting the job is. Are you doing things that have never been done before, or just compiling reports all day long?

Do you like sitting behind a pc all day or do you prefer to work with people?

Then there's life circumstance. Sometimes you may want the lesser paying job as it's more interesting, but can't due to responsibilities.
 

Jet-Fighter7700

Honorary Master
Joined
Mar 12, 2008
Messages
31,618
Thanks for that Chevron,
I guess I wish I could test drive all 3 before committing.

Let me see how it goes, as I never really had the chance to be out on the road not in a cubicle, and maybe it will be a change of scenery for me that what I need.
 

Chevron

Serial breaker of phones
Joined
Oct 2, 2007
Messages
25,900
Thanks for that Chevron,
I guess I wish I could test drive all 3 before committing.

Let me see how it goes, as I never really had the chance to be out on the road not in a cubicle, and maybe it will be a change of scenery for me that what I need.

I say go for it.

A change is as good as a holiday. :)
 

DA-LION-619

Honorary Master
Joined
Aug 22, 2009
Messages
13,777
Travelling and manager, money doesn't matter if you're miserable it will affect your productivity.
 

skeptic_SA

Executive Member
Joined
Apr 16, 2015
Messages
9,468
:p Best of luck with whichever road you choose EG. With your sunny disposition and positive outlook - whatever you choose will be good for you coz you'll make it so.
 

azbob

Honorary Master
Joined
Nov 18, 2008
Messages
36,328
Just remember to check the oil in your picanto regularly with all the driving.
 

Jet-Fighter7700

Honorary Master
Joined
Mar 12, 2008
Messages
31,618
:p Best of luck with whichever road you choose EG. With your sunny disposition and positive outlook - whatever you choose will be good for you coz you'll make it so.
Thanks skeptic,
But you still didn't tell me what you would go for?
Money,manager, or travel distance.
It's really not a clear choice for me,
 

Chevron

Serial breaker of phones
Joined
Oct 2, 2007
Messages
25,900
Thanks skeptic,
But you still didn't tell me what you would go for?
Money,manager, or travel distance.
It's really not a clear choice for me,

Do you like being stuck behind a PC all day?
 

HavocXphere

Honorary Master
Joined
Oct 19, 2007
Messages
33,155
Have given this topic a lot of thought in the past so might as well jot it down for everyone's benefit

Money >>> If they're all roughly on par then I ignore this completely. Can't make life decisions based on a couple of grand.

Travel >>> Avoid like the plague unless its travel as in other countries. And avoid Africa travel too. Also who carries the cost...can be significant. And potentially an issue if you have family.

Manager >>> Not taken into consideration at all. Maybe thats just my line of work...I report to someone else every couple of weeks.

Knowledge gain >>> Yes definitely but has to be the right kind of knowledge...needs to fit into long range planning

Office based cubicle , To road warrior driving >>> Depends on the job. If its a job where every day is different anyway then you don't need more disruption...thus office based. If its a boring job then road warrior for the change in scenery. Keeping in mind that senior staff tends to be office based so beyond a certain level you no longer get a choice here. Road warrior is a lot less glamorous than it sounds...sitting in some random boardroom gets old really fast.

You're missing:
Lifestyle - Long commute? Long hours? Leave?
Company culture
Income potential long term
Employer contrib to med aid/retirement
Opportunity to practice leadership skills
Average age of employees (see company culture above)
Training provided (esp stuff like leadership, presentation skills etc)
Support structures in place at the company
How it looks on your CV (Type of job)
How it looks on your CV (Company prestige)
Size of company - specifically in terms of stability (I wanna get paid on time)
Size of company - international transfers opportunity
Upward mobility - will I get promoted regularly or do I need to wait till someone retires
How much info you have on the company (i.e. Have a friend there thus less risky unknowns)
Overtime arrangements

I also tend to look at the recruitment process & overall vibe during this phase. e.g. I've had one interview where the person was super busy eating a salad during the interview (!). Got the job...told them to shove it.

I also eyeball their contracts / employment manual carefully because it gives insight into company culture.

lessons learned?
Based on my last one:
Strong preference for multi-nationals. International transfer kick ass because they are different (new country) yet you show up knowing exactly what you're doing (same company, culture etc).
Less emphasis on salary, more of promotion opportunities
Check tax rate & CoL carefully for international stuff
Commute is a bigger factor life-style wise than I previously though
Environment is also NB...having the beach a stone throw away is big

When younger experience matters more, when older remuneration matters more. (You need to learn to earn).
Tis true. You should aim for a decent % improvement anyway though.
 
Last edited:

cupcake

Expert Member
Joined
Dec 17, 2015
Messages
4,725
Travelling and manager, money doesn't matter if you're miserable it will affect your productivity.

I agree. IMHO a bad Manager is the #1 reason people leave a position followed by work life balance so this is spot on.
 
Top