Mmusi Maimane slams Duduzile Zuma-Sambudla for comparing Thuli Madonsela to a gorilla

Bonywasawarrioraway

Expert Member
Joined
Aug 23, 2020
Messages
1,836
Zuma is black so not sure how she can be racist against her own race. It is however dehumanizing - she's trying to say Thuli is ugly not that her race makes her a gorilla.
I see what you are saying and to a large extent that is perfectly correct.

Here is where it falls down, If I, a white male, was to say the EXACT same thing, meaning it in the EXACT same way, it would most definitely be regarded as racism. Any defence that I might mount would be torn to shreds.
The implication is that the race of the declarer determines the meaning of a declaration, and THAT is racist too.
A further implication is that white people are incapable of not being racist. This is patently absurd.
Far better we avoid these sort of comparisons entirely.
 

Grant

Honorary Master
Joined
Mar 27, 2007
Messages
60,621
Context and intent are important. I think in this context it's both racist and dehumanising, but remember when our esteemed CIC was called a monkey? The context was clearly his unmatchable stupidity, but it was turned into a racist incident. I say if the glove fits, etc. Remember George Bush and the chimp?
And then there was George from Seinfeld
 

Cosmik Debris

Honorary Master
Joined
Feb 25, 2021
Messages
35,153
Is this racist?

skynews-xi-jinping-china-president_4242941.jpg
 
Top