MPs hit out at online gambling bill

Syndyre

Honorary Master
Joined
Jan 26, 2006
Messages
16,821
What makes them arbiters of morality? I don't see the problem with gambling, some people may gamble irresponsibly but that doesn't mean there's something inherently wrong with the activity itself.

Other MPs complained that all the gambling sites are owned by whites, and that blacks are impoverished by it.

And this is just sad.
 

fusion01

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 6, 2003
Messages
285
It's business. And business makes the government money. Hell, it pays my bills. But then I'm white. And the government doesn't give a f**k: they'd rather so it go under, and those 'evil' whites punished with a certain loss of revenue. It's never this blatant, but much more subtle. But it's in the mind's eye of those concerned. I have always said that this country could easily go the route of Zimbabwe. Hell, it ruined the country economically, but it was a price that had to be paid for a positive outcome: the Whites were at least out. Whites with their online gambling businesses could hire lots of blacks, still wouldn't cut it. Why don't black people launch whatever damn business they like? This isn't a conspiracy, it's what's called 'an open market'. Something government have yet to learn about. But then it's Africa, and the finger needs to be in the pie every step of the way. What I don't understand is, whether it's black, white, or brown running the operation, government DOES make revenue, in that glorious term entitled 'taxation'. So, please ministers, leave us alone to make money, pay our taxes and those with issues regarding online gambing (addicts etc) RATHER GIVE THEM A DECENT FACILITY FOR HELP. The UK does this. Free phone help, walk-in Gamblers Anonymous centres. But then here it means spending money from the government's coffers. Heaven forbid. Easier just to blame others and try to stamp it out. Shut this down, and I just get closer to my relocation to Australia. Where I get shed of this racism, and where I get something for my taxes I pay. Rant over.
 

fusion01

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 6, 2003
Messages
285
I'd still like to know why if it's 'evil', why so many billions of people do it. Showing a lot of faith in humanity by judging it in this light. Are billions inherently 'evil'? Do we need to be punished? Who the hell are you to decide? I leave my judgements to my own concience, and let other's do the same for themselves. Unless others get hurt in the process (real crime, such as robbery and general theft in order to fund a habit) - then it's a different story. But if I keep my business nice and tidy and to myself, who the f**k do you think you are to take the moral high-ground? Especially when we all know it's smoke and mirrors. Doom this as 'evil' but corruption runs rife. Double-standards, with the latter being the real issue that should be addressed. This is just a distraction so one doesn't notice the sh*t in their own back-yard. Second rant over.
 

Shake&Bake

Party Liaison
Joined
Jan 19, 2007
Messages
22,255
"This is a moral issue, Turok said, and he told the DTI delegation that one argument Sibanda put forward in favour of the Bill - to allow the fiscus to benefit - was wrong: "In my view your approach is the wrong one," he said. "It is a social evil, that we may have to regulate to curb, but we must not make money out of it."

I'm in agreement with the fact that they should not make money out of it.

To regulate may be another issue that if tackled correctly, would be a benefit to those playing.


To curb? mmmm Social evil 'ay? :rolleyes: If the morales are bothering them so much, then get rid of alcohol. (Not my supply :p)
But if they bring morales and ethics into it then get rid of dop and fatty foods which impact poorly on people's health.

Social evil - government is a social evil - hows about we regulate or curb their salary increases.
 

quovadis

Honorary Master
Joined
Sep 10, 2004
Messages
11,174
oh come on - there aren't billions gambling online... in SA its around 75,000 active online gamblers if that - the US banned online gambling this year and it's currently illegal to interactively gamble in South Africa at the moment. The reality is that gambling is never a long term way of making money - at the end of the day the house always wins however whether or not its the same house edge as a traditional casino is the question. Computer random number generators have been proven to not be completely random.

If they do regulate it then there should be some key things introduced:
1) No deposits via credit card
2) Instant payment of winnings
3) No bonus or free money "promotions"
 

BobbyMac

Expert Member
Joined
Jan 17, 2007
Messages
3,353
this government is in no position to decide what's best for its people. Take the name changes for example...
 

quovadis

Honorary Master
Joined
Sep 10, 2004
Messages
11,174
Shut this down, and I just get closer to my relocation to Australia.

Fusion01 - in case u didnt know - online gambling in Australia is already illegal and has been for 2 or 3 years now.
 

Syndyre

Honorary Master
Joined
Jan 26, 2006
Messages
16,821
The reality is that gambling is never a long term way of making money - at the end of the day the house always wins however whether or not its the same house edge as a traditional casino is the question.

Its not supposed to be a way of making money and anyone who thinks it is has a problem, its entertainment.

If they do regulate it then there should be some key things introduced:
1) No deposits via credit card
2) Instant payment of winnings
3) No bonus or free money "promotions"

I can understand 2 but what's wrong with 1 and 3?
 

quovadis

Honorary Master
Joined
Sep 10, 2004
Messages
11,174
Its not supposed to be a way of making money and anyone who thinks it is has a problem, its entertainment.

No problem with that - just stating the facts

I can understand 2 but what's wrong with 1 and 3?

#1. The playing field for online and traditional casinos has to be the same. And alot of people use credit in the hope that they'll win and be able to pay it back. Or lose and try win back their losses with money which they do not have.

#3. It is never free money. Deposit R1000 get R5000 free subject to wagering requirements etc etc - the average guy on the street would not even understand half the terms for bonuses and promotional offers. I have no problem with online casinos saying "Here, have R500 for free.." but then it has to be the same as traditional casinos where if you win or cashout the money (without playing) it is yours. ie. No terms and conditions on that free money. Imagine Monte Casino coming up to you and saying - wait we gave you R100 for free - u can't leave till you finished wagering a total of R5000 - people would be outraged.
 

Syndyre

Honorary Master
Joined
Jan 26, 2006
Messages
16,821
No problem with that - just stating the facts

Me too. :)

#1. The playing field for online and traditional casinos has to be the same. And alot of people use credit in the hope that they'll win and be able to pay it back. Or lose and try win back their losses with money which they do not have.

Can't you use a CC at traditional casinos? There's no denying people are stupid and can behave irresponsibly, I'm just not sure I agree with the attitude that they should be saved from themselves, ultimately its their money and their responsibility. There are also plenty of people that use CC's responsibly.

#3. It is never free money. Deposit R1000 get R5000 free subject to wagering requirements etc etc - the average guy on the street would not even understand half the terms for bonuses and promotional offers. I have no problem with online casinos saying "Here, have R500 for free.." but then it has to be the same as traditional casinos where if you win or cashout the money (without playing) it is yours. ie. No terms and conditions on that free money. Imagine Monte Casino coming up to you and saying - wait we gave you R100 for free - u can't leave till you finished wagering a total of R5000 - people would be outraged.

True, I don't really know much about it, not into gambling myself.
 

quovadis

Honorary Master
Joined
Sep 10, 2004
Messages
11,174
To my knowledge you can no longer purchase to gamble at a normal casino using a credit card. Also all ATMs have to be out of sight/not visible from the gambling floor and 'x' amount of distance away.

Also remember that if you're gambling with credit you shouldn't be gambling. In addition Visa/Mastercard International actually prohibits it and places the responsiblity on the bank issuing the card should any legal action arise. SA Banks just haven't realised the potential liability yet as online gambling isn't as widespread in SA as it was in the US.
 

Syndyre

Honorary Master
Joined
Jan 26, 2006
Messages
16,821
To my knowledge you can no longer purchase to gamble at a normal casino using a credit card. Also all ATMs have to be out of sight/not visible from the gambling floor and 'x' amount of distance away.

Didn't know that, of course its easy enough to draw cash using a credit card and IME all casinos are littered with ATM's, even if they're not technically visible from the gaming floor etc.

Also remember that if you're gambling with credit you shouldn't be gambling. In addition Visa/Mastercard International actually prohibits it and places the responsiblity on the bank issuing the card should any legal action arise. SA Banks just haven't realised the potential liability yet as online gambling isn't as widespread in SA as it was in the US.

True but to a lot of people a credit card is just a convenience. If I have more than enough cash to cover my credit card balance and pay it in full at the end of the month its not really gambling with credit. Doesn't all intl online gambling occur via CC though? IIRC that was one of the ways they tried to shut it down in the US, by going after the payment processors.
 

quovadis

Honorary Master
Joined
Sep 10, 2004
Messages
11,174
I think the most responsible way for online casinos is to allow only debit card transactions. The US went after credit card processors initially (althouth the banks started it originally by introducing coded transactions) however the prohibition act was what stopped it.

Remember that drawing cash at an ATM using a credit card has a limit per cash withdrawal so in that way at least theres some sort of curb for people who might be in over their heads.

There are some interesting Australian surveys done on how peoples behaviour or irresponsibility differs with online internet casinos and traditional ones.
 

kilo39

Executive Member
Joined
Nov 17, 2005
Messages
5,425
oh come on - there aren't billions gambling online... in SA its around 75,000 active online gamblers if that - the US banned online gambling this year and it's currently illegal to interactively gamble in South Africa at the moment. The reality is that gambling is never a long term way of making money - at the end of the day the house always wins however whether or not its the same house edge as a traditional casino is the question. Computer random number generators have been proven to not be completely random.

According to industry research, more than $60 billion has been wagered on more than 200 poker sites in 2005, most of it lost or won by Americans. For the past two years, traffic on the leading Web sites has doubled about every six months. On Dec. 1 Morgan Stanley reported that Sportingbet was taking in $530,000 a day from its poker business. Partygaming has been valued as high as $12 billion since June 30, when its initial public offering in London raised more than $8 billion.
-
The players are in 24 time zones across six continents and on scores of ships at sea. As millions more virtual hands are dealt this New Year's Eve, poker seems poised to become the world's game. The World Series has already crowned champions from Australia, China, Iran, Ireland, Spain and Vietnam. While the Justice Department figures out how to proceed, our national pastime, born during Thomas Jefferson's presidency, remains a sturdy crucible in which folks from all over the planet find themselves welcome contenders.
The Poker World is Flat

Fusion01 - in case u didnt know - online gambling in Australia is already illegal and has been for 2 or 3 years now.
(if this is true post a url!) Ja, puppy dog australia, another doing the bidding of George Bush.

Its not supposed to be a way of making money and anyone who thinks it is has a problem, its entertainment.
Ah for goodness sake explain dozens of world champions and billions of dollars!

Those who might wonder what Lincoln would think of the Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act should consider what he said as an Illinois congressman in 1840. "Prohibition goes beyond the bounds of reason in that it attempts to control a man's appetite by legislation and makes crimes out of things that are not crimes. A prohibition law strikes a blow at the very principles upon which our government was founded."

YOU LOT are way behind the curve. Stop telling us how to live our lives FFS!

(the lotto and babies down toilets yet you wish to speak morality!)

As to america. Only reason I can see is 'vested interests' keeping gambling in Vegas (and nowhere else.) I wonder why? (Let us remember the history of Vegas!)
 

Syndyre

Honorary Master
Joined
Jan 26, 2006
Messages
16,821
Ah for goodness sake explain dozens of world champions and billions of dollars!

I don't mean at that sort of level, and I was referring to gambling generally and not poker. I mean the sort of person that thinks they're going to "double their food budget for the month on roulette" probably has a problem. :)

YOU LOT are way behind the curve. Stop telling us how to live our lives FFS!

I think you misinterpreted me, if you look at my posts on the thread I've consistently been against regulation and allowing people the freedom to gamble if they so choose.

(the lotto and babies down toilets yet you wish to speak morality!)

What? :confused:
 
Top