MSI AMD RADEON R9 290X LIGHTNING EDITION or MSI NVIDIA GEFORCE GTX780TI GAMING Ed ???

Pyromaniacghoul

Active Member
Joined
Oct 9, 2013
Messages
56
Hello

I can get either one of these cards mentioned above for my new build, but I'm really stuck on which one I should get.
What do you guys think?
 

ponder

Honorary Master
Joined
Jan 22, 2005
Messages
92,880
I think the 780 has a slight edge but what's the price difference?
 

Pada

Executive Member
Joined
Feb 18, 2009
Messages
8,189
I would go for the 780 Ti, due to its lower power consumption compared to the 290X. Just check the warranty lengths, because you don't want less than 3yrs on such an expensive card!

The 780 Ti also has PhysX & GSync support, where as the 290X has Mantle & TrueAudio support. Unfortunately it would still be many months before DirectX 12 gets released, which should give games another performance boost.
 

Bryn

Doubleplusgood
Joined
Oct 29, 2010
Messages
16,894
Hello

I can get either one of these cards mentioned above for my new build, but I'm really stuck on which one I should get.
What do you guys think?

The resolution that you'll be gaming at is important to consider. The Radeon has the edge at higher resolutions.
 

Pyromaniacghoul

Active Member
Joined
Oct 9, 2013
Messages
56

Is not a bit overkill? haha :p

The resolution that you'll be gaming at is important to consider. The Radeon has the edge at higher resolutions.

I'll be gaming at 1080p initially, I can't find any decently priced 1440p monitors. The monitor I'm currently buying costs R2400 (some lg 23" with IPS) so I'm not to keen to go above that cause I'm already spending a lot.
 

ponder

Honorary Master
Joined
Jan 22, 2005
Messages
92,880
Unfortunately it would still be many months before DirectX 12 gets released, which should give games another performance boost.

Some time in 2015 with game support lagging as per usual.
 

CataclysmZA

Executive Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2010
Messages
5,579
Nvidia is doing some pretty interesting stuff with their drivers and they're being very proactive about addressing CPU bottlenecks. Then there's also CUDA, Shadowplay, Adaptive V-Sync and streaming to Tegra-powered devices using Geforce Grid. If you want to do any game recording or streaming, Nvidia is by far the better choice.

Just beware though that should you ever consider a 120-144Hz monitor, AMD's GPUs don't break the Lightboost hacks with their driver releases, whereas Nvidia's drivers frequently do. And take note that not all Physx-enabled games actually run Physx optimally, some like Hawken and Borderlands 2 can bring your framerate down significantly.

I'd go with the R9 290X, especially if the cooler in use is an aftermarket one. You'll be all set for the 4K era and using the GPU for OpenCL and GPGPU calculations in games that use it to speed up the rendering process. There's also the XDMA engine, which will do some pretty interesting tricks with your system memory once AMD uses it for something other than Crossfire over PCI-E.

Plus, the Lightning edition has some serious engineering that's been done under the hood and you're getting the benefits of TrueAudio, which will become more as the software matures. Many, many dev studios are going to be using it, so being prepared for it can't hurt.

Also, before the comments start up, drivers for AMD and Nvidia are both fairly problem-free. I wouldn't use their past history with bad drivers to make decisions on which card to go for.

Some time in 2015 with game support lagging as per usual.

AFAIK, the 2015 date is actually split up into the preview launch for devs, where DX12 will be shown off properly to devs at /Build/ and games will be launched in Holiday 2015 with DX12 capability. It ties up nicely with the promise made earlier this year that /Build/ 2015 will also showcase a preview of Windows 9 with a launch possibly later that year. By that time Windows 8 will be almost three years old, which fits into the timeline between Windows 7 and 8 (2009 and 2012 launches respectively).
 
Last edited:

Brawler

Honorary Master
Joined
May 23, 2006
Messages
11,475
Is not a bit overkill? haha :p



I'll be gaming at 1080p initially, I can't find any decently priced 1440p monitors. The monitor I'm currently buying costs R2400 (some lg 23" with IPS) so I'm not to keen to go above that cause I'm already spending a lot.


Maybe spend less on GPU and more on a decent monitor? I never quite understand how people spend R10k on a GPU (overkill x2 @ 1080p) but R2k on a monitor?? Maybe its just me.
 

CataclysmZA

Executive Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2010
Messages
5,579
Maybe spend less on GPU and more on a decent monitor? I never quite understand how people spend R10k on a GPU (overkill x2 @ 1080p) but R2k on a monitor?? Maybe its just me.

In some cases it makes sense. Perhaps OP is getting the hardware side sorted before either plopping down money for another two for a multi-monitor setup, saving up for a 144Hz monitor or waiting until 4K monitors become cheaper. I'd never recommend anything more than a GTX770 or R9 280X for 1080p gaming because anything more is overkill.
 

Bryn

Doubleplusgood
Joined
Oct 29, 2010
Messages
16,894
Is not a bit overkill? haha :p



I'll be gaming at 1080p initially, I can't find any decently priced 1440p monitors. The monitor I'm currently buying costs R2400 (some lg 23" with IPS) so I'm not to keen to go above that cause I'm already spending a lot.

You need to change your priorities dude. You're spending a fortune on a video card that you're going to use with a crap monitor. Get a nice 27" and downgrade your graphics a bit. Something like a GTX770 is still an excellent card.
 

Pyromaniacghoul

Active Member
Joined
Oct 9, 2013
Messages
56
As Nag - Wesley said, I am buying all my essential hardware now. But I changed my mind about my monitor, I am going to get an Asus 144hz monitor now. I buying everything from Rebeltech and spending quite a bit so I am going to ask them if I can get some discount cause I am giving them so much business.
 

Bryn

Doubleplusgood
Joined
Oct 29, 2010
Messages
16,894
As Nag - Wesley said, I am buying all my essential hardware now. But I changed my mind about my monitor, I am going to get an Asus 144hz monitor now. I buying everything from Rebeltech and spending quite a bit so I am going to ask them if I can get some discount cause I am giving them so much business.

I'll be impressed if they discount because their prices are already about as low as possible in most cases. Profit margins must be rather tight as is.
 

Pyromaniacghoul

Active Member
Joined
Oct 9, 2013
Messages
56
I'll be impressed if they discount because their prices are already about as low as possible in most cases. Profit margins must be rather tight as is.

I will be as well :p looking for like 7% discount just to make my cost back down to 30k...
 

Bryn

Doubleplusgood
Joined
Oct 29, 2010
Messages
16,894
I will be as well :p looking for like 7% discount just to make my cost back down to 30k...

That's asking way too much I think. They don't accept credit cards because of the 5% commission charged by banks.
 
Top