Need a new bed. Springs or Foam?

Pho3nix

The Legend
Joined
Jul 31, 2009
Messages
30,589
Hi,

As topic above, have lower back pain and I'm not really feeling a difference when I test the beds out at the shops so I'm a little confused as too which is better. Springs or Foam.
Opinions and recommendations would be appreciated.
 

PhreakBoy

Executive Member
Joined
Aug 26, 2008
Messages
7,231
I had a casual job in a bed sales shop when I was in school 20 odd years ago.

5 years back I bought a Genessi bed and do not regret it. It's foam layers. Wife and I both prefer firm beds, so went for one without a "pillow-top". The pillow-top is a softer layer sewn to the top of the bed to give a soft feel for sleeping, but you still have the benefit of the firm bed underneath it.

I turn ours every few months just to get rid of any body "denting" that may be there. Admittedly, after turning, the bed feels like a whole different bed again.

Either foam or spring should be fine if you buy a decent bed - don't cheap out. You spend on average 8 hours (or a third of your life) i on your bed.
 

Pho3nix

The Legend
Joined
Jul 31, 2009
Messages
30,589
I had a casual job in a bed sales shop when I was in school 20 odd years ago.

5 years back I bought a Genessi bed and do not regret it. It's foam layers. Wife and I both prefer firm beds, so went for one without a "pillow-top". The pillow-top is a softer layer sewn to the top of the bed to give a soft feel for sleeping, but you still have the benefit of the firm bed underneath it.

I turn ours every few months just to get rid of any body "denting" that may be there. Admittedly, after turning, the bed feels like a whole different bed again.

Either foam or spring should be fine if you buy a decent bed - don't cheap out. You spend on average 8 hours (or a third of your life) i on your bed.

Not looking to cheap out but can't go more than 10k at this point as have other things to get :|
Was hearing issues about springs not being the best because they eventually start to slump inwards.

Can replace the bed in a couple months but need something "decent" for the moment that won't leave my back feeling like *****
 

Akasha

Executive Member
Joined
Mar 11, 2014
Messages
9,106
My foam bed makes my back problems worse. But to be fair, so does my bf's hard spring mattress
 

shooter69

Expert Member
Joined
Jun 4, 2012
Messages
3,104
Reviews don't seem too good :|

I do not really care about the reviews much as personal experience trumps it. :crylaugh:

I tested a range of beds over a couple of months by going to the shops and lay on the beds for 10 min each. Not enough time to get real world feel of it but helped a lot. The Genisi bed as described earlier was my second option.

ps. I bought myself a Cloud nine single matress when I was 19 with my first pay check. Years later gave it to my brother who still sleeps on it. The matress is now 11 years old and still feels solid.
 
Last edited:

Drifter

Honorary Master
Joined
Dec 19, 2012
Messages
22,825
We have had our Cloud Nine for about 15 years now, and the mattress is still as good as the day we got it.
 

digitalis

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 27, 2013
Messages
160
I thought I'd move to foam about 10 years ago. First I had a Cloud Nine. Omg I hated that mattress. Too HOT and back pain from hell.
Got rid of it after about a year.
Then I had a independent pocket coil mattress. Better than the Cloud Nine but i still had back pain. That mattress lasted 3 years.
Now I have a Tempur top of the range. Jeez do I hate this mattress. I wake up in a major sweat every night. Had to install a ceiling fan (best thing ever). Back pain hasn't gone anywhere. I spent so much money on this mattress I'm stuck with it. Every time I sleep elsewhere on a cheap sprung mattress I sleep like a baby.
So my 2cents: F**k foam.
 

Pho3nix

The Legend
Joined
Jul 31, 2009
Messages
30,589
I do not really care about the reviews much as personal experience trumps it. :crylaugh:

I tested a range of beds over a couple of months by going to the shops and lay on the beds for 10 min each. Not enough time to get real world feel of it but helped a lot. The Genisi bed as described earlier was my second option.

ps. I bought myself a Cloud nine single matress when I was 19 with my first pay check. Years later gave it to my brother who still sleeps on it. The matress is now 11 years old and still feels solid.

Does he know what you were doing on it :erm:
Will try go to the shop today and give the bed a proper try.
 

mercurial

MyBB Legend
Joined
Jun 12, 2007
Messages
40,902
I thought I'd move to foam about 10 years ago. First I had a Cloud Nine. Omg I hated that mattress. Too HOT and back pain from hell.
Got rid of it after about a year.
Then I had a independent pocket coil mattress. Better than the Cloud Nine but i still had back pain. That mattress lasted 3 years.
Now I have a Tempur top of the range. Jeez do I hate this mattress. I wake up in a major sweat every night. Had to install a ceiling fan (best thing ever). Back pain hasn't gone anywhere. I spent so much money on this mattress I'm stuck with it. Every time I sleep elsewhere on a cheap sprung mattress I sleep like a baby.
So my 2cents: F**k foam.

Your body hasn't been gentrified yet.

/runs
 

Pho3nix

The Legend
Joined
Jul 31, 2009
Messages
30,589
I thought I'd move to foam about 10 years ago. First I had a Cloud Nine. Omg I hated that mattress. Too HOT and back pain from hell.
Got rid of it after about a year.
Then I had a independent pocket coil mattress. Better than the Cloud Nine but i still had back pain. That mattress lasted 3 years.
Now I have a Tempur top of the range. Jeez do I hate this mattress. I wake up in a major sweat every night. Had to install a ceiling fan (best thing ever). Back pain hasn't gone anywhere. I spent so much money on this mattress I'm stuck with it. Every time I sleep elsewhere on a cheap sprung mattress I sleep like a baby.
So my 2cents: F**k foam.

Why'd you try foam so many times then?.. masochist?
 
Top