Your current Panel Values are
VOC 45.33V
Vmp 37.99V
Isc 13.79A
Imp 12.90A
Best panel would be the below that I can see is available
Canadian Solar 540W Super High Power Mono PERC HiKU with MC4-EVO2
VOC 49.2V
Vmp 41.3V
Isc 13.9A
Imp 13.08A
Because everything is connected up in series always try to have the closest match because
the panels will add the additional few volts, in your case depending on the degradation
of the panels cells and what they produced from first day they was connected.
Your Voltage will increase around 2 - 4v but atleast you would still be able to match up the
same current(A) from your panels.
With mixing and matching in series, the system takes on the additional volts but it
will match the lowest produced amps throughout the string. Any panel with a lower imp
than your current panels will derate the entire bang lot on the roof you have.
The below is a nice blog that helped me understand more when the suppliers wasn't able
to give me a direct answer.
Mixing Solar Panels: Discover Now Dos and Dont's of Mixing the Same Types or Different Types of Solar Panels. Act Now to Save Your Money!
solarpanelsvenue.com
Why are there so many voltages listed on solar panels? What is open circuit voltage, voltage at max power for solar panel output?
www.altestore.com