Pain management : Is John E. Sarno a Genius or a Quack

Hosehead

Executive Member
Joined
Aug 15, 2008
Messages
7,838
I have a really sore knee that responds well to drugs, shoe inserts and bracing. I'm too young for a knee replacement. I have good days and hellish days with pain.

My brother had crippling back pain a few years ago. He couldn't move. His wife gave him Sarno's book and according to the old Mother he was up and has never looked back.

I googled and all I can find is more positive accolades for this man than Einstein and his unconventional methods and his Pain theory. (a convoluted Freudian based mind over matter affair) Personally I have long thrown out any Freudian theory having dismissed it all as the crazed ravings of a coke addled, sex besotted Madman.

I told the old mother that nothing was really helping my damaged knee 100% except industrial strength pharmaceuticals and, besides x-rays don't lie about the extent of the damage . She (an obscure type of Yoga instructor which we don't have here yet) said that I should "read Sarno" and two of her friends, both with knee problems, needing knee replacements had cancelled their ops after reading Sarno, and in the one friend, "her knees responded to her removing herself from some ongoing stresses, in six months she was pain free." and this friend " has always been pretty good at, communicating with her subconscious, and ignoring limitations and lack that might emerge from those hidded depths." but, after a long email interrogation, just short of a virtual waterboarding, she admitted to me the other friend "unfortunately comes under the 5% that cannnot be helped, unless psychotherapy is also used."

So what I want to know is does anyone have experience with the Sarno method of pain control which in a nutshell is this:
Sarno treats patients by convincing them that their anger or rage or whatever emotion being repressed is the true cause of their pain and that there is no actual damage to the body parts that hurt. Patients are encouraged to return to normal activity, cease physical therapy and possibly undergo psychological therapy. According to Sarno, once the client recognizes the symptoms for what they really are, they go away.

Is he a Messiah or just another mainstream medicine avoiding Quack. I'd like to know because it seems so many people swear by his methods and I can't seem to find much that refutes them.
 

sal12344

Senior Member
Joined
Nov 21, 2008
Messages
947
Quack...had one try to convince me my pain was because I am angry ad my parents or some ****. So the fact that I was rear ended by a truck which destroyed my car, and pushed me into a stationery car in front of me had nothing to do with it!!
 

Celine

Executive Member
Joined
Aug 25, 2008
Messages
5,711
what a load of codswallop. a person can condition one's mind to control pain to a certain extent. however, if something happens such as a bone breaking on top of existing pain, then it is impossible to control even the pain you are controlling, if you know what i mean.
 

syntax

Executive Member
Joined
May 16, 2008
Messages
8,663
doesnt sound like something i would even try.

but i do try other things some people think is BS like a chiropractor (which saves my back from the squash punishment like you would not believe)

Have you tried going to a biokineticist? They obviously cant repair damage already there, but i have had very good results working with one. Strengthening parts that need it, which has had very good results with pains and issues all over my body.
 

RiaX

Executive Member
Joined
Jul 2, 2012
Messages
7,217
utter rubbish. Joint pains are common especially if you exercise and dont do it properly. Your joint is damaged there is no emotions behind the mysterious pain. Its damaged you can ultrasound it or MRI it and it will show damage. The fact that you stand and stuff means the joint/muscles/tendons etc are always in use so they cant heal as other areas becuase they bare your weight all the time.

Its there you can test is objectively you can see the damage and therefore you can conclude the damage is real.

SO yeah quack
 

Hosehead

Executive Member
Joined
Aug 15, 2008
Messages
7,838
Well if its utter rubbish why the accolades. I am a bit confused. Howard Stern.(read the comments following the vid on you tube) [video=youtube_share;iYIOOURMuS0]http://youtu.be/iYIOOURMuS0[/video]
Senate hearing
On February 14, 2012, John Sarno, MD appeared before the Senate Committee on Health, Education, and Pensions to address 'Pain in America: Exploring Challenges to Relief'. The committee was chaired by Senator Tom Harkin (D-Iowa) who was very supportive of the mind-body connection espoused by Dr. Sarno's treatment approach to pain. In fact Senator Harkin describes his own successful experience with pain relief from reading Dr. Sarno's books. Senator Harkin relates how his niece's chronic pain symptomatology from fibromyalgia resolved after reading Dr. Sarno's books as well.

Source http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_E._Sarno


The Senate Hearing on Chronic Pain

Medical doctors testified on Americans suffering from chronic pain. They focused on preventative treatment and research into chronic pain, as well as myths about causes of chronic pain.

Video and Transcript here http://www.c-spanvideo.org/program/304421-1
 
Last edited:

RiaX

Executive Member
Joined
Jul 2, 2012
Messages
7,217
homeopathy and psychic mediums have accolades too. Just saying
 

Hosehead

Executive Member
Joined
Aug 15, 2008
Messages
7,838
Lets drag DJ out of whichever rock he's hiding under. Let him comment.
 
Top