Rental - Pontiac G6 - Subaru Impreza - Chevy HHR - what would you chose ?

[Frankie]

The local Avis office has three cars in the category I that falls in my company allowance - we get a special rate for ultra long rental periods.
1) Pontiac G6 (3.5L)
2) Subaru Inpreza 2.5i Premium
3) Chevy HHR

Number 3 is just to ugly, so it's a toss up between 1 and 2.

I've driven the G6 and it's really comfy and powerful, but I hear the Subaru is a sporty drive.

What would you chose?

 

[ponder]

The Subaru.

The US does not make cars, it makes boats on wheels.

 

[defcomk]

Impreza Got my vote

 

[Frankie]

Thanks.

My wife is keen on the G6, but I think I'll go and test drive the Impreza on Saturday.

 

[HapticSimian]

Hmmmmmm... If I recall, the G6 shares its platform with the SAAB 9-3, so it might not be all bad. I'd be tempted by the opportunity to drive something 'different', although I suppose it is an everyday car across the pond.

All things considered, the Subaru would be the more logical choice.

 

[MisterBigglesworth]

Impreza - No contest...

 

[thedutchman]

the pontiac is a nice V6

 

[BCO]

Impreza g0g0g0.

 

[Velenoso]

If you want something comfortable, go for the G6, I've driven one and it's a nice cruiser. Easy to drive. Subaru is a lot sportier on the other hand.

 

[BCO]

If you want something comfortable, go for the G6, I've driven one and it's a nice cruiser. Easy to drive. Subaru is a lot sportier on the other hand.

My Impreza is super comfortable (I'm talking a Camry-style ride on the open road). I think that a US spec non-WRX/STI should be set up for cruising as well.

 

[ToxicBunny]

The G6 shares its platform with the Saab 9-3 iirc, but its dumbed down BIGTIME for the americans..

I'd take the Impreza ANY day of the week