"Sabotage by ANC central gov against people of Western Cape" - Bart Henderson

Arthur

Honorary Master
Joined
Aug 7, 2003
Messages
24,196
I received this in a WhatsApp group. Did a quick check whether it's posted elsewhere on MyBB but found nothing, so here goes.

I'd never heard of Bart Henderson before this, and know nothing about him or his creds.

Disturbing if true. My first question is: If true, why isn't this front and centre in all messaging from the WC and Cape Town governments? Is this guy a crank? Any truth to this? Especially worrying are the Umgeni Water allegations.

Bart Henderson on WhatsApp said:
WHAT DO I THINK IS REALLY GOING ON BEHIND THE CAPE TOWN WATER CRISES SHOW?

By Bart Henderson

Fraud risk management specialist. Author, lecturer, analyst, columnist. CEO Henderson Solutions. Responsible for major fraud investigations.


I've been asked a few times. So I've taken a bit of time to answer to save airtime and circumvent the inability to do so adequately on WhatsApp or Twitter

So let me get this straight. #Drought #WesternCape #DayZero This has taken me quite a while to figure out. Cape Town is facing running out of water. A major metropole. The implications do not affect Cape Town or Western Cape. The implications affect the whole nation.

Granted the citizens on the coal face are Capetonians but make no mistake the citizens of South Africa will feel the pain.

The Cape is a material contributor to the national economy. There are millions of citizens around the country who have family, relatives and friends living in the Western Cape.

What is staring a major metropole in the face is a reflection of what is and has been happening in increasing numbers of small and large towns across the country.

This latter fact has been largely ignored. Out of sight out of mind. Its out in the open now.

This water crises is about BULK water supply and who controls it. That's it, nothing more.

It's about power.

Under the law, the Western Cape government can NOT supply BULK water. This means under law Western Cape Government cannot build dams or engage in any activity related to making provision for their own future water security.

Bulk water supply is the exclusive purview of the National Department of Water Affairs and Sanitation (DWAS) under a Minister in the ANC Government and this purview extends to every drop of water stored and supplied in BULK (Dams and one day DESALINATION PLANTS) in the whole of South Africa.

As recently as 14 December 2017, the Minister of Water Affairs sent a letter to Hellen Zille instructing the Western Cape Government, or advising if you prefer, that Government had appointed Umgeni Water out of KwaZulu Natal to come solve the problem by building a desalination plant in Cape Town.

The directive goes on to reference a site at the V&A Waterfront, the exact site earmarked by the Western Cape Government months ago in their emergency response to the looming catastrophe.

However, in the case of the Western Cape Government response, their plans are in a far advanced stage, with EOI and tenders in some instances concluded.

Changing course now will delay the building of this desalination plant by months.

So what gives?

Well, Umgeni Water is where Government redeployed Dudu Myeni after she brought SAA to its knees.

She is a master of obfuscation, dishonesty, deceit and deception.

The Ministers directive is meant to portray Government taking charge and coming to the rescue, when in fact it's about who controls the capital expense and who gets the tender.

In October 2017 newspaper reports indicate Umgeni Water might soon be in need of a R3-billion bailout.

Newspapers also ran stories regarding an interim Board being appointed at 'embattled' Umgeni Water by Minister Nomvula Mokonyane.

Newspapers reported a letter to Mokonyane, lawyers acting for asset manager Futuregrowth accused the minister of illegally appointing Msizi Cele as both Umgeni's acting chief executive and accounting officer; illegally replacing Cele with Thami Hlongwa in both positions; and giving herself the power to appoint chief executives.

Futuregrowth holds Umgeni Water bonds as Asset Manager for Old Mutual.

So let's get this straight.

You have a patently tainted SOE dispatched with alacrity to solve a water crises by a Minister in a patently tainted Government controlled by a patently tainted Zuma cabinet in a Province controlled by an opposition party, in the greater interests of its citizens who voted against you.

A province that already has the distinction of having the only major metropole with its entire main line shut down. Another service under the exclusive purview of National Government provided by SOE Metro Rail and Transnet.

Imagine the SOWETO main line being shut down indefinitely.

Coincidence?

I don't think so. But that's another story.

It's about many, many things.

But really it's about the HIV/AIDS pandemic and Government response under Mbeki. When we turned to beetroot and cabbage remedy mentality in response to a catastrophe that many suggest claimed 300 000 lives.

I strongly suspect it was the realisation of money to be made that shifted government policy from beetroot to condoms and ARV's hence their obsession with the supply of former and latter with safer sex campaigns almost non existent today.

It's about the demonstration of total contempt for the value of human lives.

It's also about gross mismanagement, gross inefficiency, gross negligence, gross incompetence, gross ignorance, gross shortsightedness, ostrich mentality and State Capture.

Which in turn, is all about who has the power and who controls the water once it starts flowing again because they will control the revenue and the province and with that a leverage of power.

Which point to deliberate and consequential political, economic and industrial sabotage on a devastating scale by the ANC central Government against the entire people of the Western Cape.

If you think of the current national government as some benevolent uncle you are deeply mistaken as mistaken in thinking National Government is dealing with the crises with any genuine intent, appetite or desire much less honesty, transparency or genuine concern for its people.

Do you really believe after years of scandals, of corruption, ineptitude and plunder the Government has all of a sudden turned some invisible corner?

After being fed a daily diet of bile, a diet of abuse of power, abuse of state, abuse of resources and revenue, of patronage, State capture and haemorrhaging economy by National Government are you still going to suggest this crises belongs anywhere else whatsoever other than on the shoulders of those who own it?

I think not.

If you think Provincial Government are getting any bi-partisan co-operation, to resolve this crises from Zuma's government you've got flies in your brains.

The Western Cape is the potential trigger point for a hoped for and intended national disaster I am increasingly coming to strongly suspect.

Business Day, 29 January 2018 - "Cape Town risks having its municipal bonds cut to junk by Moody’s because of its water crisis.

"Two of Cape Town’s main industries, tourism and agriculture, are likely to decline [because of the water crisis], reducing employment, gross value added and tax income," Moody’s associate analyst Daniel Mazibuko wrote in a research note released on Monday.

"Other effects include threats to public health from poor sanitation and, more generally, to social order, which is significant given Cape Town’s marked income inequality.""

What this is saying in a nutshell is that Cape Town as ground zero is potentially the epicentre of potential civil unrest which will start among the poor and spread to engulf the entire peninsula and beyond.


... ctd below
 
Last edited:

Arthur

Honorary Master
Joined
Aug 7, 2003
Messages
24,196
[quote='"ctd from above"]
...ctd from above

If ever the time and opportunity were present to fan the flames of anarchy, dissention and revolution in this country for the many being primed to hate by a post Mandela ANC, this is it.

It has the potential to prove the ideal recipe for state intervention leading to a state of emergency, the imposition of martial law and very possibly lead to wider civil unrest and even civil war.

All of this while Zuma remains in power and ultimate control of the ANC Government and supported by a minority by smallest of margin of most those belonging to the ANC Political Party.

So when next you read or talk about the crises in Western Cape ask your self who stands to lose most by not finding a solution and who stands to gain most by one not being found.

Then ask yourself who has the power to do something.

If the one with the power to do something also happens to be the one who benefits the most from infrastructure, service and delivery collapse, it stands to reason they have a conflict of interest.

It is a conflict that arises naturally out of the conflation of Party and State, where the political party sees itself as the State because they are the majority party in Government.

Which of course they're not because we are after all a multi party Democracy.

The ANC furthers the aims of its supporters and State furthers the aims of the people.

There is not a shadow of doubt in my mind that the crises unfolding in the Western Cape is in great part attributable to a corrupt and dysfunctional ANC.

There is little to sweet bugger all Western Cape Government can do about it except try alert people and do whatever they can to get people to use less water.

This in the face of social media campaign's of 'unknown' origin openly encouraging the grand scale wastage of tap water to push the City of Cape Town over the brink and into total anarchy.

In my mind this is no more or less just another opportunity to open a new front in a political, economic and ideological war steeped in race based dogma and hate.

The sooner the people of the Western Cape realise how much they are despised and resented by their ANC government and the sooner they realise what their elected Provincial government is up against the better.

So thank all of you who've been asking for my analysis of late of the situation in the Western Cape.

After many attempts to answer on the fly and time it takes I decided to write it down so you and others who want can read it at your leisure.

Please if you think my analysis or hypothesis have merit please send to your friends.

Finally, vasbyt. Be kind to one another. Stand together and help anyone you can. Above all SAVE WATER as if your life depend on it. Start petitions and demand Central Government release your taxes to Western Cape Government to build desalination plants now and to fund other measures.

If it's about control, Province can build it and allow Government to buy it back.

So stop shouting at Province and start shouting at Government.[/quote]

Could there be anything to this?

If so, what can be done about it?
 

2012

Executive Member
Joined
Jan 22, 2012
Messages
8,526
Feels "Dunning–Kruger"y with a touch of tin foil hat.

Would read better if there were links to articles and decisions.

And it doesn't excuse the City's (aka DA) handling of the crisis with "mis-information" and unpopular/late by-laws.
 

Gordon_R

Executive Member
Joined
Jul 5, 2009
Messages
7,929
TL;DR

There is always a small element of truth to conspiracy theories. We have rehashed the stories many times in the forum mega-thread. I don't have the time (or energy) to contribute to a rebuttal.
 

R13...

Honorary Master
Joined
Aug 4, 2008
Messages
30,375
If the DA truly believed the ANC national department were in the wrong they'd have run to the courts to force their hand. That they didn't tells you, this social media commentary is to be taken well salted
 

Gordon_R

Executive Member
Joined
Jul 5, 2009
Messages
7,929
If the DA truly believed the ANC national department were in the wrong they'd have run to the courts to force their hand. That they didn't tells you, this social media commentary is to be taken well salted
It is possible to have benign (or malign) neglect, but much harder to prove, than intentional acts, or a conspiracy theory...
 

Arthur

Honorary Master
Joined
Aug 7, 2003
Messages
24,196
Makes sense. Sorry, haven't been following the drought threads so didn't see this previously discussed.

I must say the piece above is poorly written. It was laced with spelling errors (I corrected the most egregious) and really isn't up to scratch for an ostensible author.

My only lingering question is whether there's any truth to the alleged imposition by the national Ministry of Taps and Toilets of an almost-bankrupt Umgeni Water on the V&A Waterfront?
 

Gordon_R

Executive Member
Joined
Jul 5, 2009
Messages
7,929
Makes sense. Sorry, haven't been following the drought threads so didn't see this previously discussed.

I must say the piece above is poorly written. It was laced with spelling errors (I corrected the most egregious) and really isn't up to scratch for an ostensible author.

My only lingering question is whether there's any truth to the alleged imposition by the national Ministry of Taps and Toilets of an almost-bankrupt Umgeni Water on the V&A Waterfront?
That is absolutely true, but was rejected immediately by the CoCT.
 

zolly

Expert Member
Joined
Sep 1, 2005
Messages
2,830
If the DA truly believed the ANC national department were in the wrong they'd have run to the courts to force their hand. That they didn't tells you, this social media commentary is to be taken well salted
Zille has a response to why they haven't yet pursued a legal challenge (yet) in a piece she wrote today:

https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/opinionista/2018-02-05-from-the-inside-day-zero-memes-and-myths-abound-lets-get-back-to-essentials/

In regards to the post, I will say what I said about it before. It's mostly nonsense in that it could lead to a civil war that could destabilise Southern Africa. What is potentially true: ANC stalling processes to impact the image of the DA (but they will step in at the last minute to be seen as the "saviours" because ultimately, if Cape Town were to "collapse" it would send negative shockwaves through the whole of SA and will also have an impact on the ANC), and corruption at national govt level.
 
Last edited:
Top