Shapped versus Un-Shapped

Joined
Aug 29, 2006
Messages
24
Ok, so I am a bit dof :eek: and there are like way too many threads here to see if this question has already been asked and answered a thousand times.

Can somebody please explain to me in simple terms wtf is shapped and unshapped? :confused:

Thanks
 

bwana

MyBroadband
Super Moderator
Joined
Feb 23, 2005
Messages
89,424
Shaping places a priority on ports and protocols so things like http, ftp, and email get a priority at the expense of other things such as peer to peer applications (like bit torrents and even skype).

Since the introduction of the ADSL regs last month shaping is now illegal and should be reported to ICASA if the ISP refuses to abide by the regulations.

EDIT - from TelkomInternet
Shaped ~ In layman’s terms, the shaped service prioritises keystroke activities - things you do while sitting in-front of your PC. So when you’re surfing your favourite site, doing your banking or checking you e-mail, this option will work best for you.

For those of you that need to know more, read on. The shaped service distinguishes between the various protocols used over the Internet. The main priority is HTTP. At present, all international HTTP traffic is transparently cached for ADSL users. All international un-cached data is shaped. The following un-cached protocols are prioritised on the network: HTTP (in certain cases HTTP is not cached due to website incompatibilities), HTTPS, FTP, Mail (POP3, SMTP and IMAP), SSH and TELNET. Any protocol not mentioned above will receive a lower priority on the network.

Unshaped ~ In layman’s terms, whichever activity you are doing or leaving your PC to do, while not there, all available bandwidth will be used for this application or protocol.

This service will offer you unshaped international bandwidth and a higher data transfer rate. The unshaped service will not shape the un-cached protocols. All protocols will therefore share the available bandwidth equally. Similarly, local bandwidth will remain as is with no shaping implemented. Keeping this in mind, this service is typically designed for a niche market including, for example, your typical Forex Trader, specific gaming applications, secure work from home options and VPN’s. All these applications can use unfamiliar protocols, which are not necessarily bandwidth intensive but require an unshaped service to work optimally.
 
Last edited:

qdada

Expert Member
Joined
Nov 19, 2003
Messages
1,416
Shaping places a priority on ports and protocols so things like http, ftp, and email get a priority at the expense of other things such as peer to peer applications (like bit torrents and even skype).

Since the introduction of the ADSL regs last month shaping is now illegal and should be reported to ICASA if the ISP refuses to abide by the regulations.

EDIT - from TelkomInternethttp://www.telkomsa.net/products/adsl_telkom_internet.jsp

are you serious ?

does this effectively nullify Telkoms uncapped 4gb service and similar uncapped data plans offered by the smaller isp's like Axxess and Openweb ?
 

bwana

MyBroadband
Super Moderator
Joined
Feb 23, 2005
Messages
89,424
are you serious ?

does this effectively nullify Telkoms uncapped 4gb service and similar uncapped data plans offered by the smaller isp's like Axxess and Openweb ?
Section 5
Telkom, SNO, and ISPs shall not be allowed to impose port prioritisation on their subscribers
It not only nullifies them but IMHO makes them illegal.
 

qdada

Expert Member
Joined
Nov 19, 2003
Messages
1,416
thank goodness u understood my question, that was meant to read...

does this effectively nullify Telkoms 3g shaped service and similar SHAPED data plans from other ISP's
 

qdada

Expert Member
Joined
Nov 19, 2003
Messages
1,416
Oh yeah that would hide your powers as a telepath very effectivley, i should wear a foil helmet before logging on this forum :)
 

broken1

Expert Member
Joined
Jul 25, 2006
Messages
1,686
So...if shaping is not "illegal" when can we expect unshaped ADSL? (Telkomintenet is my ISP - sadly)
 

bwana

MyBroadband
Super Moderator
Joined
Feb 23, 2005
Messages
89,424
So...if shaping is not "illegal" when can we expect unshaped ADSL? (Telkomintenet is my ISP - sadly)
You mean if it is illegal - send a complaint into ICASA.
 

bwana

MyBroadband
Super Moderator
Joined
Feb 23, 2005
Messages
89,424
ha ha ha, illegal? what a joke!!! if it is soo "illegal" why does telkom advertise these "illegal" activities???? this is south africa everyone, nothing will every change, we will ALWAYS be a third world country!

http://www.telkominternet.co.za/products/adsl_telkom_internet.jsp - tell me shaping is illegal after u look at that!
There arent degrees of legality - ICASA passed the Act - it was gazetted and it now stands as law.

So yeah - read the act and tell me its not illegal.
 
Top