South African Covid-19 News and Discussions 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Mar 6, 2004
Messages
41,694

well done CPT!

Let's see how Gauteng handles the next few weeks, been hearing things are falling apart, even in some private hospitals

Nice video - also exposes the rubbish initial modelling the government relied on with regards to deaths.
 

Lupus

Honorary Master
Joined
Apr 25, 2006
Messages
50,973
Based on a whole number? Surely it should be based on a number of cases/population? That would make EC or WC by far more cases/population than GP.
Yup people still focusing on totals, though active cases currently would be a good guage, you're correct in taking into account the per population figure.
 
Joined
Mar 6, 2004
Messages
41,694
Based on a whole number? Surely it should be based on a number of cases/population? That would make EC or WC by far more cases/population than GP.

Gauteng will eventually get to similar cases per population as the WC. But as @sand_man pointed out, it's actually the active cases that are probably more important than total cases and GP is well ahead there.
 
Last edited:

pinball wizard

Honorary Master
Joined
Feb 9, 2010
Messages
34,361
L


Gauteng will eventually get to similar cases per population as the WC. But as @sand_man pointed out, it's actually the active cases that is probably more important than total cases and GP is well ahead there.
Bullspit. The only number that matters is the hospitalised/hospital beds. Testing is meaningless. Treat symptomatically.

(as to your quoted story, I don't read garbage that says things like " the wuhan of whatever" and "bush medicine". Daily Maverick scraping the bottom of the journalistic barrel as well I see.)
 

Geoff.D

Honorary Master
Joined
Aug 4, 2005
Messages
26,878
So in hindsight, trying to establish what GPs strategy was.
1. Believe in everything the WHO said and says.
2. Rush off and build a field hospital without equipping it for oxygen distribution.
3. Dig lots of graves.
4. Take thousands of swabs for testing but delay processing to determine if there are lots of infections.
 
Joined
Mar 6, 2004
Messages
41,694
Bullspit. The only number that matters is the hospitalised/hospital beds. Testing is meaningless. Treat symptomatically.

(as to your quoted story, I don't read garbage that says things like " the wuhan of whatever" and "bush medicine". Daily Maverick scraping the bottom of the journalistic barrel as well I see.)

Ok, but Gauteng has the most people on hospital beds, in ICU and on ventilation. But yes, they also have the greatest capacity of all provinces but all reports suggest many hospitals are already overloaded.

1594282419074.png
 

pinball wizard

Honorary Master
Joined
Feb 9, 2010
Messages
34,361
So in hindsight, trying to establish what GPs strategy was.
1. Believe in everything the WHO said and says.
2. Rush off and build a field hospital without equipping it for oxygen distribution.
3. Dig lots of graves.
4. Take thousands of swabs for testing but delay processing to determine if there are lots of infections.
Point by point if you will.

1. There was a national strategy. Don't be that guy who pretends (or worse - believes) that the WC magically didn't follow the NCC at th outset.
2. At least an attempt was made. The EC has no field hospitals bar that one VW made. Does the field hospital at the ICC in CT have all the bells and whistles? Like I said, varying degrees of completeness reached during the fattening of the herb.
3. Graves? I asked on that graves thread for proof/address of where this grave site is being dug. I'm still waiting. I call BS on this, as the deaths are still minimal - especially compared to the WC - in GP.
4. Stop with the lies. There is a massive population differential between GP and every other province in SA. Any laboratory system will struggle to get results out timeously with a massive influx of tets. Unlike the WC, Gauteng conducts tests (currently, I know it might change) across the board, not isolated age groups. There isn't some grand conspiracy to fake GP's numbers. The dead don't lie.
 

pinball wizard

Honorary Master
Joined
Feb 9, 2010
Messages
34,361
Ok, but Gauteng has the most people in hospital beds, in ICU and on ventilation.
Our curve (rate of infections) is on the rise, the WC's is stable. It's basic maths. When WC was increasing massively, the same was seen. Also, we have many more Karens who will demand a bed in a hospital even when their doctor says they can treat at home.
 

tetrasect

Executive Member
Joined
Aug 22, 2009
Messages
9,101
Based on a whole number? Surely it should be based on a number of cases/population? That would make EC or WC by far more cases/population than GP.

If you dropped 10 infected people in an area with 1 million population and another 10 people in an area with 100 million population, the numbers in each area would go up at the same rate. So after a while it would be 2000 cases per 1 million in one area and 2000 cases per 100 million in the other area. That says nothing about how each area is handling the crisis.

Per population data only makes sense after the virus has been eliminated (not gonna happen) or we reach herd immunity. Then we can count the deaths/population to see how well we did.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top