I love these threads
After phoning 5 or 6 insurance companies, and I think 5 brokers now, Outsurance is still the cheapest for me by 10% (one other company quoted me 70% higher and wouldnt drop a cent). My excesses are usually lower too
I've also claimed twice, premiums didnt go up and both claims processed within 3 days (money in my account). It's all about finding the company who's risk profile places you lowest and who's service you can live with.
I'd love to know how this happens. But insurance fees are like bank charges; black magic baby.