Thank you for your detailed response to my concerns regarding the recent phishing attempts. However, I believe there is a conflict between your initial and subsequent statements that requires clarification.
In your first response, you stated:
In your follow-up, you emphasized:
Here’s where the inconsistency arises:
- None of the registrant email addresses associated with my domains are tied to the same domains I've been mailed about. (they arent @ the same domain they contacted me regarding)
- Despite this, the phishing emails I’ve received specifically target the correct registrant email address for each corresponding domain. This pattern cannot be explained by guesswork, automated tools, or generic phishing techniques.
Additionally:
- None of my registrant addresses use common aliases like admin@ or info@, which are often guessed by scammers.
- Some phishing emails were sent to ProtonMail accounts, which are highly secure with second passwords and 2fa tokens only I have access to, making unauthorized access extremely unlikely. (unless you are claiming they hacked every single mailbox they contact - highly unlikely)
The only logical conclusion is that the scammers have access to a record of which email address is associated with each domain. This strongly suggests that the registrant email information has been exposed in some form, even if inadvertently.
While I appreciate your assurance that your systems have not been compromised, the precise targeting of registrant email addresses contradicts the notion that this is purely due to publicly accessible or guessed information.
I look forward to your thoughts on this matter, as it’s crucial to understand how these emails are being so accurately directed.