Judging time.
I was recently having a discussion with my brother in law about what is a good photo? He told me that each photo is good in its own right, and it depends on what effect you are actually going for. If you are able to achieve that, then its is a good photo, Regardless if nobody else likes it. Certain photo's that I love, somebody else might hate.
Since I choose the topic, I had a preconceived idea of what "Urban Photography" was all about and I guess I am basing my decision on what effect I "wanted" to achieve.
First: Rouxenator
It captured MY ideal the best. I loved all the different angles which seem to pull you towards the centre of the image. So even if it wasn't 100% urban. Its the closest to what I feel the topic was about.
Second: Morpheos
I loved this photo and there is nothing wrong with it. Other than to me it fits more into a night time category, than urban photography.
Third: Tosser
An awesome shot (BTW, do you have a link to a bigger image. I don't have you on my contact list in Flickr yet so couldn't see it). Though for me personally again, It has to much rural and mountain in for the topic as I envisioned it
PS: I know there were many others that wanted to take but never submitted. I'll start a thread once I get some of mine downloaded and edited so hopefully we can show of more of this topic if anyone is interested?