Why South Africa is changing its plug standard

phoneJunky

Executive Member
Joined
Apr 3, 2009
Messages
6,270
I've definitely popped a vein or two with those damned things.
The best route is to change the plug.
TBH I'd rather have standard 2-point plugs all over. I do understand the limitations and electrical issues it could cause is bad though.

How much did you pay per 'new' plug to replace it on your tools?
It was R7,90 per plug when I bought 20 black plugs and 20 white plugs. But that was back in 2017/2018 and it was at the only place I could find them back then (livecopper).


I see they are R18 now.
 

grok

Honorary Master
Joined
Dec 20, 2007
Messages
28,737
So.. the reason is so "you'll cut down on the number of adapters needed", but you'll have to re-do all the plugpoints in your house to achieve that?

1604412426689.png
 

|tera|

Master of Messengers
Joined
Mar 31, 2006
Messages
25,906
It was R7,90 per plug when I bought 20 black plugs and 20 white plugs. But that was back in 2017/2018 and it was at the only place I could find them back then (livecopper).


I see they are R18 now.
I love the colours.
Makes it easier to label certain electrical devices.
So.. the reason is so "you'll cut down on the number of adapters needed", but you'll have to re-do all the plugpoints in your house to achieve that?

View attachment 945630
Yep. As Jan said though. There's no requirement or regulations forcing you to do it though.
 

phoneJunky

Executive Member
Joined
Apr 3, 2009
Messages
6,270
So.. the reason is so "you'll cut down on the number of adapters needed", but you'll have to re-do all the plugpoints in your house to achieve that?

View attachment 945630

Again you don't have to. New houses need to have these ones in there. But I did replace all my sockets as I found it worked better for me after I did my entertainment area. All the kitchen ones I left as hybrid though to cater for new appliances.
 

Rickster

EVGA Fanatic
Joined
Jul 31, 2012
Messages
20,459
I honestly think the ZA 3 prong plug is one of the best, it may take up a lot of space but the connection is great. It doesnt pull out at all at the wall because the pins are at a right angle to the cable.

The US plugs are a joke...
 

Moto Guzzi

Expert Member
Joined
Apr 24, 2004
Messages
2,190
Meet Mr Willy De Nilly. if you cannot Reboot, Update or Upgrade, you replace. Because you were not sure of your engineering practices, so theres no guarantee for this either.
 

Swa

Honorary Master
Joined
May 4, 2012
Messages
31,217
How were we too invested in it? It was only adopted recently after everyone rejected it. Everyone else saw what a waste it was. It isn't even too late now to "pull the plug" and just let everyone who want them install the new plugs.

We still don't have a real reason.
 

Swa

Honorary Master
Joined
May 4, 2012
Messages
31,217
I would have written the headline more like "SA is first country to adopt international standard for plugs". For it's a great move as many of my devices are two prong so these will fit in fine and the old three pin plugs wasted tons of space. Something few mention is two prong plugs are great from a safety perspective in terms of being able to be pulled straight out by the cable in an emergency - no ways that happens with the old three prong plugs. There is good reason for having international standards and interoperability should be supported. Hopefully other countries adopt the standard over time too.
Only if it's wired on top. I haven't seen any that are.

Except that isn't what happens:
standards.png


I do like the new plugs though, I just think there is some unwarranted optimism about how successful it will be.

The problem is that the only other country that seems to use it is Brazil.
Except they don't. They have their own version of it and it looks like we are heading in that direction as well. What you posted is accurate. Standards don't just become because someone invented a new one. They are adopted from existing ones. Unlikely this one will win out. Most likely scenario is there will be new ones for new power technologies and one of those will win out. We are just adding another unnecessary step.
 

ThinkCentre

Expert Member
Joined
Mar 8, 2011
Messages
3,404
The real reason behind this is that people want to make money! Not save it!
 

phoneJunky

Executive Member
Joined
Apr 3, 2009
Messages
6,270
This will be the big one. Until TVs, fridges, washing machines and toasters come with the new plug, there is very little incentive for anyone to change their sockets.
Yes, that is why my kitchen is currently hybrid. But most TVs comes with a 2 point plug which will fit in this socket.
 

Willie Trombone

Honorary Master
Joined
Jul 18, 2008
Messages
60,038
For what it's worth, in response to the detractors in this thread: I like the new plug standard.

South Africa got stuck on the old British World War 2-era BS546 standard while the rest of the world moved on to better standards.

Would it have been better for South Africa to adopt the new flat-pin British plug standard, Schuko, or the Australian standard? Maybe.

Instead, as a small fish in a big ocean we decided to throw our lots in with the global standardisation body (IEC). From where I'm sitting, that's a perfectly rational thing to do. When the international body resposible for electrotechnical standards embarks on a project to standardise the whole 250V world's plugs and sockets that's a pretty noble goal to get behind.

I would far rather that we stay the course and adopt a standard that is interchangeable with Europlug, and ultimately get rid of those irritating Schuko plugs altogether in time, than see the country dither like we did with the digital TV migration.

As a reminder: part of the reason for South Africa's current spectrum mess is because the 2010 administration of the Department of Communications decided to throw out the standard that the whole industry had agreed-upon back in 2005.

I'm all for refining standards, or migrating to newer, better standards, but to halt a process halfway is not a good call.

Plus, for all we know, South Africa's adoption of the standard might help reignite debates in other countries to get the whole 250V world converge on one standard. It's unlikely, but a man can dream.

(Regarding my Schuko remarks: It's a fine standard, but I honestly think IEC 60906-1 is better as it is more compact.)
FWIW so do I.
My posts were tongue in cheek.
What I struggle with is the speed at which the wheel turns.
Suppliers are slow to adopt.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jan
Top