Word associated with Christianity and British history taken out of the dictionary

PeterCH

Honorary Master
Joined
Aug 8, 2005
Messages
18,371
I take your point - I had not thought of things in that way. I'd be interested in what PeterCH makes of your post.

I think everyone's experiences are different.

A physician, should know how to listen but also know what questions to ask. The interview or consultation process is therepeutic in itself already but one needs to be a good detective too and that's IMO what clinical medicine is about.

Someone has a problem. It could be organic or psychogenic or a combination. Either way, the problem is serious for them, ie their perception of it causes them anxiety
which perpetuates the problem.
One has to realise this and help the person cope with the implications of his problem by offering support but one also has to make sure the problem
isn't organic in the first place.

Traditionally schools have taught medical conditions to their students and how these present. They also taught the impact of these presentations on the patient,
but maybe not in such a well integrated way as in the new system which also focuses on the individual patient in terms of his community, his family, partner etc;
his personal expectations, his social expectations, his community expectations etc. It think all of that is grand, but people need to be able to diagnose first
and foremost, once they are competent at that, they can branch out and assume a more therapeutic role.
 
Last edited:

pos(t)er

Expert Member
Joined
May 14, 2008
Messages
1,777
Doesn't this physician thing have something to do with the African idea that a doctor should look at the patient holistically.
 

PeterCH

Honorary Master
Joined
Aug 8, 2005
Messages
18,371
Doesn't this physician thing have something to do with the African idea that a doctor should look at the patient holistically.

It's not an African idea at all. The holistic approach as said is good, but one can't be a master of all trades and secondly it shouldn't detriment the bread and butter of the clinical practice - that is finding the cause of the problem the patient is experiencing.
 

pos(t)er

Expert Member
Joined
May 14, 2008
Messages
1,777
It's not an African idea at all. The holistic approach as said is good, but one can't be a master of all trades and secondly it shouldn't detriment the bread and butter of the clinical practice - that is finding the cause of the problem the patient is experiencing.

Of course it's not only an African idea, but i specifically remember seeing a doccie in which Western medicine is pitted against traditional african medicine, with the claim that african doctors take a more holistic approach, which is why we may be seeing it implemented in SA?

But i agree, speciliasation is much more effective.
 

Albereth

Honorary Master
Joined
Apr 26, 2005
Messages
15,860
Does holistic medicine include a second opinion from the ancestors?

Western medicine had its roots in the same space that 'African medicine' now finds itself. It just moved on a few thousand years.
 
Top