Ivy’s last-minute spanner
Matsepe-Casaburri’s announcement comes on the eve of the day set for the deregulation of the telecommunications industry, and is contradictory to the more liberalised line that has been taken by the industry’s regulator, the Independent Communications Authority of South Africa (Icasa).
Vans operators“ smaller telecoms businesses and internet service providers (ISPs) who lease Telkom’s infrastructure and provide services on top of that were heartened by the Minister’s September 2004 determinations, which laid the foundation for a more liberalised market. However, her determinations left much room for interpretation, resulting in confusion for how businesses should proceed with developing new offerings yet still remain within the boundaries of the law. Icasa did clarify in draft Vans regulations and in media release in November Vans will be a any manufacturer.
Wanting to provide clarity on the government’s intentions, the Minister issued a statement regarding the licensing of Vans that reads: ‘The issue of self provisioning was issued in the government’s policy determinations only in relation to mobile cellular operators in terms of fixed links, to give full meaning to the intention to reduce the costs of telecommunication services in South Africa, it is the intention that value-added network operators may obtain facilities from any licensed operator and as specified in the determinations.’
She added that it is not the government’s intention to license every single activity that can be provided by a Vans operator as this ‘would lead to an absurd result’, and assured the sector that the Convergence Bill, when tabled in Parliament, “will bring much needed certainty to the sector in this regard’.
Incumbent fixed-line operator Telkom is naturally pleased with the clarification according to its spokesperson, Xolisa Vapi: ‘The clarification is in line with our position, and we agree that Vans should not be allowed to self-provide.’ At the hearings held by Icasa around drawing up new licenses for Vans in the deregulated environment, Telkom make it clear that it believed enabling the Vans to self-provide would require a legislative amendment.
Janet MacKenzie, a director at Cliffe Dekker Attorneys who specialises in telecommunications law, says that the minister’s statement severely limits the competitive benefits that would have been derived had Vans been able to self-provide as initially stipulated by Icasa: ‘Vans will no longer have an alternative means of service delivery and will still be dependent on other licensees in respect of their provision of services to end users. This may also impact negatively on the cost of these services. There are certain aspects of the minister’s statement which may require further clarification, and this may result in a further delays.’
The industry’s reaction to the statement has been one of disappointment. “There has been a lot of energy and entrepreneurial activity in the sector since the September determinations, especially in the wireless space, as this is technology of choice for Vans to implement for self-provision,†says Tim Parsonson, joint CEO of Storm Telecoms.
“South Africa was to witness a potential explosion in new technologies, and become a leader in the field. The statement restricts business and is definitely a step back.’ Parsonson says. But, he remains positive because of the legalisation of VoIP (Voice over Internet Protocol), enabling the Vans to offer voice services. Storm itself will launch a VoIP service to for corporate clients on 1 February.
Mike van den Bergh, chairman of the Communications Users Association of South Africa (Cuasa), which represents Vans, says that there should not be an impact on the potential for competition in the short-term, but this will be critical to address later on: ‘This will result in delayed savings for consumers. Icasa has published draft regulations regarding charges, and if these go through they will result in cost savings for Vans. However, the cost base will still remain inflated.’
Van den Bergh says that although Vans were not going to lay fibre optic cables everywhere, many were considering wireless technology in order to provide last-mile solutions that did not require Telkom infrastructure: ‘There has been a lot of confusion about which companies will be able to provide infrastructural services for themselves. We thought that Icasa had been specific on the issue, and we thought we could self-provide.’
Some commentators expressed a feeling of unease at the Minister’s apparent backtracking, saying it smacked of an incumbent putting pressure on the government. But Vapi, Telkom’s spokesperson, refused to comment on this.