Cheapest, lowest, first
Similarly, the operators are striving to be able to claim to offer the best value, or to be the cheapest. The problem seems to be that the various package offering are so complicated that it seems difficult to compare directly and see who really is the cheapest.
On Friday last week, Vodacom announced a price cut of up to 50% for pre-paid and some contract customers between 5pm and 8pm during weekdays, for Vodacom-to-Vodacom calls. The new rate is R1,49 per minute. The announcement caused a big stir, knocking prices of the telecoms companies on the JSE. The cuts were effective from last Sunday, and Vodacom has launched a widespread advertising campaign to announce the innovation, which it is calling “Happy Hours”. Vodacom CEO Alan Knott-Craig said he expected the cuts to drive revenue as people spoke for longer.
But, MTN says it was actually first at slashing after hour rates. Vodacom’s cuts were in fact a response to its value offering.
MTN released a statement this week saying that it had introduced an “innovative” lower off-peak call rate for pre-paid customers a few weeks ago, which it calls the MTN WOW WOW bundle: “This step sparked a flurry of rate cuts in the industry to keep up with MTN innovation”, it said.
MTN said that over the same weekend that its main competitor – Vodacom – had spent hundreds of thousands of rand to announce a price cut promotion for calls made within their own network, it had managed to sell more than 100 000 starter packs in its value promotion.
The WOW WOW bundle, according to MTN’s website, includes a 50% discount on calls between 5pm and 9pm on weekdays, as well as a number of free and cheaper SMS (text) and MMS (multimedia) messages, and other features for pre-paid customers.
On Thursday, the third operator, Cell C, released its quarterly performance figures, and declared that it continued to offer “the best value” to its subscribers, listing a number of ‘firsts’, ‘lowests’ and ‘onlys’ – such as offering the lowest any destination, off-peak, per second prepaid rate of 98c for the subscribers four most used numbers, and being the only network to offer per second billing across all packages.
Then, later on Thursday, Vodacom announced further tariff cuts of up to 17% to R2,99 on all pre-paid calls from 7pm to 8pm, based on per second billing, and across calls to all networks and operators. But, there will be some increases for Vodacom customers – which is in the process of filing with regulator Icasa – from R1 to R1,05 in the off-peak pre-paid rate, and increases for the upper end packages; 1,5% for Talk 500 rates, and 2,2% for Talk 1000 rates.
Mobile tariffs have been under the spotlight for the past few months, with Icasa recently conducting hearings into the effect of handset subsidies on the mobile market. There have also been complaints laid with the Competition Commission (by a consumer) and with Icasa, by the Communications Users Association of South Africa (Cuasa), the latter which lodged a formal complaint with Icasa around mobile call costs in June.
Every operator will claim to be the cheapest and the first. Whatever the truth is, as long as the operators keep chipping away at tariffs, and the others follow suite to remain competitive, then the competitive landscape must be working to gradually bring down costs. Whether costs are coming down by enough will always be subjective. Perhaps the answer was best put by Knott-Craig last week on the Moneyweb Power Hour when he said: “At the end of the day, you can’t price a service below the cost, and you can’t price a service in such a way that the return to the people who are investing the money to build the networks find that this is an unsatisfactory investment… it is a balance and, at the end of the day, I don’t think you can really satisfy either party entirely. I think the trick is to find the balance where you can satisfy both parties as much as you can.”
Source: http://www.moneyweb.co.za