Cellphone users treated to real rivalry
THE three cellular network operators have finally woken from their noncompetitive torpor to engage in some real rivalry, with price cuts and counter cuts finally benefiting end users.
The cuts have been accompanied by an entertaining war of words, with each claiming to be the cheapest, the most innovative and the most customer-friendly.
Consumers can thank the Independent Communications Authority of SA for the skirmish, as Icasa is investigating the high cost of cellular services.
And even before the hearings are scheduled, the networks have slashed their fees.
Vodacom made a splash with its Happy Hour promotion, dropping its prices up to 55% during the peak hours between 7am and 8pm — but only for calls to other Vodacom numbers.
MTN instantly hit back, claiming it was the first to drop its rates, but without the public fanfare.
MTN’s new packages cut 50% off calls to MTN or Telkom lines and 36% off calls to other networks between 5pm and 9pm. Its SMS fees dived 50%.
Vodacom replied with a further 17% cut, this time for calls to other networks.
Cell C has not cut its rates, but said its fees were already highly competitive.
Icasa’s inquiry is not the sole reason for the rapid-fire reductions. Both MTN and Vodacom have dropped their prices to induce customers to make calls over a longer period each evening, to ease congestion at the peak time of 8pm.
“To be really honest, this wasn’t about dropping the rates, it was about addressing the 8pm peak,” said Maanda Manyatshe, MD of MTN SA. “All of us have a problem because our subscribers make 8pm calls, so we are trying to even the load on the networks.
“We can’t continue investing to build a network for the 8pm peak because during the day the use of that capacity is very low.”
MTN developed new packages rather than a straight cut, Manyatshe said, because people respond to bundled packages, not quick tariff cuts.
He doubts Vodacom will succeed in spreading its call load with discounts from 5pm to 8pm. People rarely change their calling patterns, he argues, so most users will not benefit from Vodacom’s cuts because they will not change their behaviour.
Manyatshe would not comment on how much the lower fees would hit MTN’s overall profitability. But with a net profit of R6,4bn on revenue of R29bn for financial 2005, it certainly has room to manoeuvre. Vodacom’s net profit of R3,9bn on revenue of R27,3bn also gives critics plenty of fuel to accuse it of profiteering.
Vodacom CEO Alan Knott Craig says the cuts will save customers hundreds of millions of rands. “We expect traffic to increase, offsetting to some degree the cost of these reductions.”
The lower prices will certainly be highlighted by the operators when they plead with Icasa not to force their tariffs down. The inquiry was triggered by a complaint from the Communications Users Association of SA (Cuasa).
“For Vodacom to announce two cuts in a week isn’t normal. It’s a reaction and a counterreaction and I hope it’s the beginning of a downward trend,” says Cuasa spokesman Ray Webber. “Vodacom’s new rate of R2,99 a minute is still a lot of money, but it’s better than R3,60.”
The reduction will affect prepaid users too, so 80%-90% of cellphone users could benefit, Webber says.
But the changes have not benefited business users — Vodacom is raising the cost of two business packages in October.
Webber doubts the cuts will be sufficient to quell Icasa’s suspicion that fees are still too high. “The operators are trying to dissipate some of the arguments but I don’t think it’s nearly enough.”
Cell C’s Jonathan Newman does not believe SA’s tariffs are out of line with international trends or with the cost of providing the services. “We expect Icasa to do the appropriate market studies and we expect the results will show there is no need for intervention,” he says.
“We are getting questions about the Vodacom and MTN cuts, but it’s pretty clear Cell C is already offering very good value.”
INet-Bridge