Technology26.09.2005

Telkom wields the axe

ON MONDAY, after a sumptuous weekend conference held at Sun City for Telkom’s corporate customers, the telecommunications company gave three of its key employees “leave of absence”.

Surprisingly, one of those who did not survive the night was head of sales and marketing Pinky Moholi, who hosted the conference and is said to be highly regarded by her clients, some of Telkom’s most important customers. She was also one of the people tipped to replace chief executive Sizwe Nxasana, who left at the end of last month.

The morning after the conference, Moholi was called in and told of her suspension. She left the building before she could be escorted out by security guards.

Executive director Belinda Williams and human resources group executive Oupa Magashula were then summoned in turn, according to some close to events. They were told of the decision to suspend them, and after being allowed a quick visit to their offices, were ordered to hand in their access cards and were escorted from the building.

A day later Telkom announced that Moholi, Williams and Magashula had been suspended. It gave no further details and the suspended employees aren’t talking, because of an agreement with Telkom. But it is believed that in late August the three objected to the board about a lack of corporate governance regarding the appointments of CEO Papi Molotsane, Reuben September, who was appointed to the vacant post of chief operating officer, and Mandla Ngcobo, who became corporate affairs head.

The suspended trio are said to have voiced concern that there was no proper process in the appointees’ selection, including invitations, advertising and interviewing for the positions.

“The first time they heard about Papi’s appointment was when they read it in Business Day,” says somebody close to the trio.

At the same time, a new structure was announced whereby the three were essentially demoted without consultation.

But Telkom spokesman Lulu Letlape denies they were demoted. “It was just a change in the structure.”

Williams, who had been group executive corporate affairs, became group executive investor relations. She was relieved of her corporate communications and mergers and acquisitions portfolios and, instead of reporting directly to the chief executive as before, she was told to report to Ngcobo, who was moved from legal services.

Moholi, who also previously reported to the chief executive, was told to report to September and lost two of her key portfolios — Telkom Directory Services and Swiftnet. The chief executives of both these divisions had reported to her.

Magashula was also effectively demoted, being told to report to September instead of the chief executive and also lost his Telkom Foundation portfolio.

“The board felt that the new chief executive shouldn’t have so many people reporting to him,” says Letlape. “It wanted to simplify the structures.”

Besides appointing Molotsane, Letlape points out that the board also selected September and Ngcobo. “Normally, top management are appointed by the chief executive, but the board made these appointments as it felt the new chief executive would need support when he arrived. Once he has been in the position for a while, he can make changes.”

The positions weren’t advertised internally and internal candidates weren’t given the opportunity to apply. “Pinky would have applied for Reuben’s job if she’d known about it,” an insider says. “She wasn’t even given an opportunity to be interviewed.”

No letters were handed to the demoted trio explaining their new positions. Moholi used the formal grievance procedure process to find out why, but received no answer.

However, Letlape says everyone was informed that the structure would change.

Moholi was suspended when September approached Molotsane to complain about insubordination.

Another insider says that Moholi never had a good relationship with the chairman, Nomazizi Mtshotshisa. Letlape says only the chief executive would have liaised with the chairman.

There is also talk that the decision to let Nxasana leave at the end of August, instead of December when he was meant to, took place informally, without all board members present.

Letlape says that in selecting a new chief executive the board appointed and mandated an external search company, Mindcor. The company came back with its recommendations and this was reduced to a shortlist of three. But internal candidates were not on the list.

“The search company wasn’t given specifics,” Letlape says. “It worked on what the board was looking for.”

Nxasana says he wasn’t involved in the selection of the new chief executive. “The process was run by the non-executives. I can’t comment on what is going on at Telkom now as I haven’t been involved in it. But I can vouch for the three individuals. They are some of the best in their industries.”

On Friday the Communication Workers’ Union weighed in to the matter.

President Joe Chauke issued a statement saying that structures at Telkom created by old equity partners (Thintana Communications) had to be reviewed and said “the company should be given the benefit of doubt and not allow the universal practised norms [of suspending employees] to cause any brouhaha. We therefore urge all Telkom employees to respect the process and not allow any disgruntled executives to use them as pawns for their unfulfilled desires.”

Yet many investors are also angry at the way the changes to the management structure were made. “We’re not here to tell management what to do, but they should have contacted us and told us what was happening,” says Old Mutual Asset Management telecoms analyst Steve Minnaar. “These are drastic measures which could have an impact on the value of our shares.”

Telkom undertook some damage control on Friday and met investors.

A meeting scheduled for tomorrow, set up about a month ago by Andisa Securities for investors and analysts, will probably also be used to provide an update.

Once the enquiry has been finalised, the three suspended employees are unlikely to return — even if they win their case — given the bad blood between them and the new order at Telkom.

Inet-Bridge

Show comments

Latest news

More news

Trending news

Poll

What is the download speed of your home Internet connection?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter