LIGHTS, WATER, INTERNET
Mkhatshwa can afford to be confident. New legislation is set to clear up uncertainty about whether Tshwane and other municipalities could legally build their own telecom networks to compete with Telkom and the cellular operators.
The Electronic Communications Bill (formerly the Convergence Bill) was unanimously passed by parliament this week and allows municipalities to build their own networks without having to engage Telkom.
The new act will open the way for municipalities to build networks without the fear of legal challenge. "A city such as Tshwane has been building a fibre backbone. It will now, as a licence-exempt private telecom network owner, be able openly to resell capacity to a commercial operator," says Democratic Alliance MP Dene Smuts, who has been involved in the drafting of the new law.
Charles Kuun, who oversees Tshwane’s network plans, is the loudest voice in the call for SA cities to build their own telecom networks. Such networks are seen as a way for cities to cut their operating costs and, in certain instances, to provide some kind of free telecom service to residents.
Tshwane has been at the forefront of municipal telecom efforts. It wants to provide every resident with an e-mail address and cover the city in what it calls a "broadband cloud" by 2010.
Other municipalities have not done nearly as much. Few have even investigated the option of building their own networks or leasing capacity on existing systems. A change to existing legislation, introduced earlier this year ahead of the gazetting of the Electronic Communications Bill, allows town councils that have private telecom network (PTN) licences to sell spare capacity on their networks to licensed telecom companies. But existing law allows local governments to operate networks only on "one piece of private land". It is not clear whether they can cross public roads, even though they own them.
The industry regulator, the Independent Communications Authority of SA (Icasa), does not believe this uncertainty should be used as an excuse. Icasa councillor Zolisa Masiza says the authority regards public roads as municipal property and will not penalise a municipality for running telecom networks across them.
Delegates at a digital cities conference, held last week in Midrand, agreed that the problem was not with networks crossing municipally controlled land but with them crossing national roads and rail tracks not owned by municipalities.
However, Masiza says the bigger problem is that there is little interest by local governments in deploying their own networks. "Of the 284 municipalities in SA, only seven have applied for PTN licences," he says.
Conference delegates also complained that Icasa, before it issues PTN licences, asks for details that can be supplied only once municipalities have awarded third-party service providers with tenders to build networks. This means they take the risk of awarding a tender for a licence they might not get.
Representatives of municipalities at the conference insisted, however, that they were serious about operating their own networks. Raven Naidoo, technology adviser to the Cape Town unicity, says if it were to build its own network, it would be able to save an enormous amount of money on internal calls.
Having its own network would also allow Cape Town to provide services to residents.
Johannesburg, too, is considering building a network, using wireless technology, for internal communication. At current telecom prices, Johannesburg could set up a citywide Wi-Fi network and recoup the cost within three or four months through reduced telephone bills, says Herklaas du Plessis, the city’s acting director for IT.
The impact of cheaper telephony on poor communities must not be underestimated, says UniNet CEO David Jarvis. UniNet has built a commercial broadband wireless Internet service using Wi-Fi technology in Cape Town and has recently also put one in place in Knysna, with the local council. The service will allow residents to make free calls within the municipal district using designated payphones.
It’s not only municipalities that are interested in Wi-Fi networks. The Eastern Cape government wants to use the technology to communicate with its 300 clinics.
Local governments have an important role to play in fostering broadband access to the broader population, says Greg Richardson, the founder of Civitium, a US-based technology company that consults to municipalities.
Some critics have argued that government, through municipalities, should not be involved in building telecom networks and that this should be left to private investors. But Richardson says there is no basis to this argument. In the same way as roads and running water are supplied by municipalities, municipal networks could improve the quality of life for residents. The state should be seen as a partner, not a competitor, he says.
Richardson says he is not surprised SA is following the examples set by some US cities, such as Philadelphia, that have gone into partnership with the private sector. By getting access to municipal property and assets, companies can build citywide telecom infrastructure in exchange for providing some kind of basic service to residents.
(c) Financial Mail,
Reproduced with permission