Technology17.11.2005

Party poorer

For the first time in years the financial outlook is not all party hats and streamers
 
How much longer can the party continue? That was the question from analysts and shareholders this week as the fixed-line operator and its associate company Vodacom again shot the lights out with their financial results.

It’s good news for shareholders; less so for consumers unhappy about high telecommunications prices. In the six months to September 30, Telkom, which still enjoys a monopoly over fixed-line communications, lifted operating profit by 37,3%, or R2bn, to R7,5bn on sales of R23,5bn, producing a healthy profit margin of 32%. Headline EPS for the six months rose 35% to R7,76.

Most of the growth in sales came from 50%-owned affiliate Vodacom. The cellular operator, SA’s largest, lifted revenue by 22,3% (against 4% growth in Telkom’s fixed-line business) on the back of a 41,8% surge in customer numbers to 19,1m. But Telkom contributed to strong growth on the bottom line. Further aggressive cost-cutting helped lift profits; an 18% reduction in head count, for example, resulted in a 9,6% decline in employee expenses.

New Telkom CEO Papi Molotsane, who replaced Sizwe Nxasana in September, says there will be no let-up in the drive to lower operating costs. However, the focus will no longer be principally on reducing staff numbers. Instead, Telkom is concentrating on cutting costs in its supply chain, he says.

For the first time in years, though, the financial outlook for Telkom is becoming murkier. Regulatory and policy pressure, combined with the introduction of the second network operator (SNO) and other new competitors, could force the company to reduce its prices faster than it had hoped it would have to.

When government granted Telkom a five-year extension to its monopoly in 1997, the operator took maximum advantage to ramp up its prices. This period of exclusivity should have ended in 2002, but, thanks to a lack of investor interest and bungling by government, the introduction of the SNO soon descended into farce, which has allowed Telkom to continue to extract monopoly rents from its customers.

But the environment is changing – fast. Molotsane acknowledges that one of his biggest challenges will be to balance the very different demands of Telkom shareholders. Government, which still holds 38% of the group’s equity, has made it clear that telecom prices have to come down. To do this, it has proposed a number of interventions, the most far-reaching of which is that the local loop (the "last mile" of copper cables that connect consumers to Telkom’s telephone exchanges) be unbundled. This would allow rivals direct access to consumers, without having to work through Telkom. This, and other proposals by government, do not necessarily square with the demands of private shareholders.

But Molotsane believes they can be balanced, for the most part. On some issues, though, he will not budge. For example, he says he will resist any attempts by government to have the landing stations for the submarine telecom cables that link SA with Europe and Asia declared an essential facility.

This proposal, if implemented, would allow rivals access to the cables at much-reduced prices and should help bring down SA’s high bandwidth costs. "It’s a Telkom asset. The shareholders have invested in that asset," he says.

Others might argue that Telkom’s investment was made when it was a majority state-owned utility and that the investment was effectively funded by taxpayers. However, Telkom was partially privatised on the basis that it included the cable asset.

Despite the growing policy and regulatory pressure on Telkom to reduce its prices, Molotsane says there are several areas where he believes Telkom can continue to grow revenue and profit. They include:

Broadband – Molotsane wants to increase the penetration of broadband (fast Internet access) from 2% of its customer base today to up to 20%, or almost 1m customers, in the next three years. At the end of September, Telkom had only 95 290 broadband digital subscriber lines in use. Molotsane says he will not rule out the option of subsidising the rapid roll-out of these lines. If Telkom slashes the price of broadband now, it could take firm control of the market just as the SNO is trying to establish a foothold in this area.

Triple-play services delivering telephony, Internet and video-on-demand – by mid-2006, Telkom will launch a trial network, together with Microsoft and Alcatel, to test the delivery of television via the Internet (known as IPTV ).

Cellular and fixed-mobility – Telkom is testing new wireless broadband technologies, including WiMax, as it looks for ways of delivering services to areas where its fixed-line network cannot accommodate broadband services.

Expansion in Africa – the company is exploring opportunities in Kenya, the Democratic Republic of Congo, Angola and Nigeria. Molotsane says Telkom won’t make investments that are not in the interests of shareholders. In the case of Nigeria, where Telkom is conducting a due diligence of fixed-line operator Nitel, he says: "It’s a business that needs a lot of help but it’s a business that can be fixed. The decision [about whether to invest] will have to be made [and] we will be brutal in interrogating the numbers."
Molotsane also says a closer working arrangement with Vodacom is imperative. The two companies have historically had a tense relationship. It’s of concern to Molotsane that Telkom and Vodacom operate at arm’s length and do not leverage one another’s assets.

Telkom’s interest in Vodacom is not surprising. The cellphone company has more than four times as many clients as Telkom and growth is showing no signs of letting up. Vodacom (in SA and the rest of Africa) now has more customers than Vodafone has in each of the UK, France, Spain and Japan. Only Vodafone’s operations in North America, China, Italy and Germany still have more subscribers each than Vodacom does, says group CEO Alan Knott-Craig.

Knott-Craig expects SA will have 43m cellphone users by 2011 – that’s nine in every 10 people, including children and babies, so many people are expected to have more than one cellphone.

Inet-Bridge || Discuss this article

Show comments

Latest news

More news

Trending news

Poll

What is the download speed of your home Internet connection?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter