A warning note
The SA music scene is booming but piracy threatens to undermine recent successes
Rock musician Arno Carstens and kwaito star Mduduzi "Mandoza" Tshabalala, despite their different backgrounds, have set the local music scene alight. Over the past two years they have been among the top-selling artists in SA, with sales of more than 100 000 albums each. The "sold out" signs go up days before they perform at concerts.
Their songs appeal to black and white fans alike. They have also toured abroad, showcasing local genres to new markets.
"They have broad crossover appeal and have performed on the same stage on a number of occasions," says Melanie Machattie of AC Music, which represents Carstens.
The growth in stature of the two artists has mirrored the surprising success of the local music industry in general.
One estimate is that the industry is worth R2bn/year. In 2000 that figure was estimated at US$150m (R1bn). This includes primarily sales of music merchandise (CDs, cassettes and vinyl), but also payments to song writers, producers of music and videos and concert promoters, and royalty payments. Marketing and promotion spending is also part of the R2bn revenue.
Getting precise figures is difficult as no single organisation represents all stakeholders in the industry. Instead, various organisations separately represent musicians, record companies, producers, promoters and technicians. Figures from the International Federation of the Phonographic Industry (IFPI), the body representing the $33bn international music industry, show that SA is ranked 19th in music sales by value, accounting for 1% of global music sales. At current exchange rates this amounts to about R1,5bn ($237m), less than 2% the size of the US, the biggest music market, with annual sales of around $12,1bn.
Still, the IFPI says that while global music sales fell by 7,6% in 2004, and by 20% year on year from 2000, SA unit sales were up by 22% from 18,1m units in 2003 to 22,1m last year . This has boosted retail sales to R888m in 2004, a significant rise from R785m in 2003, according to the Recording Industry of SA (Risa), a member of IFPI.
Employment figures are equally difficult to come by . Estimates vary from 5 000 to 10 000 people employed full-time in the sector, with the same number finding work in the concert industry and other music-related events.
The lack of industry-wide information is one of the features that marginalises the industry and makes it more difficult to attract large financial investors.
Nicholas Motsatse of the SA Music Rights Organisation (Samro) and Gallo Records CEO Ivor Haarburger say this is being addressed.
"The lack of data has not earned us the respect we believe we deserve as an industry, but we are working on it through initiatives like the Moshito conference," says Motsatse.
Moshito is an annual music conference and trade exhibition aimed at improving the image and marketability of the local music industry.
This is not to say that the industry is not doing well. And local artists in particular are benefiting from the growth in demand.
Another reason for its relative success is that multinational record companies such as Sony, EMI, BMG and Virgin Records have reinvested in SA, while a number of independent SA record companies – Bula Music, Serepta Music, Sheer Sounds and Kalawa Jazzmee, among others – are successfully promoting local artists. Many of these independent labels originated in the kwaito music explosion of the 1990s .
Kwaito is a local music genre using a composite of international and local sounds – a mixture of house, bubblegum, township rap and R&B. But though many kwaito artists were discovered by the independents, they still have to rely on the big labels for their distribution networks and marketing budgets.
Perhaps the biggest contributor to the SA industry is the resurgence in popularity of domestic music, after a slump in the late 1980s . Traditional music such as that by Ladysmith Black Mambazo has continued to fan the fortunes of companies like Gallo Records, but the new genres are also fuelling demand.
Haarburger says the SA industry’s infrastructure functions well and is positioned to expand in the near future.
But official sales are being undermined by pirated sales, which account for an estimated 25%-35% of the total value. The technological revolution that makes it easy to copy and download music at home is another challenge. Balancing the need to encourage online sales, through digital stores and other initiatives, with the prevention of piracy has proved difficult for the SA industry.
Risa, which represents more than 95% of recognised music recording companies in SA, says piracy is a big drain on the music industry as it deprives artists, songwriters and record producers of the just rewards for their creativity.
Braam Schoeman, manager of the antipiracy enforcement unit at Risa, estimates that the industry stands to lose R500m to illegal sales in 2005 . On a global scale, the IFPI says one in three music discs sold worldwide is an illegal copy, a staggering $4,6bn market globally. "But if we have to look at what people pay for the poor-quality counterfeit product and what the recording industry, artists and promoters lose, the damage is far bigger. In addition, the SA taxman loses out through lower customs and tax payments," says Schoeman.
Risa GM David du Plessis says music from artists such as Mandoza and Carstens is most at risk from pirates . "A pirate may be a criminal, but he is not stupid – it’s the big names that do well even in the world of piracy," he says.
In SA and other African countries, music cassettes are still the most often counterfeited products because they are substantially cheaper than DVDs.
Risa says efforts are being made to curb music piracy, including the identification of pirate manufacturers. "It is not just about hitting the guy in the street who is making a living from selling counterfeits. We have to hit the guys who are making them ," says Schoeman. Risa is also going on an education drive, targeting schools and tertiary institutions, where the lower costs are particularly attractive, to help change attitudes.
Because of slow computer penetration in Africa, digital piracy has not grown that much. Also, limitations with broadband access have helped restrict illegal downloading of music.
Another challenge facing the sector is the digitisation of the industry and the growth of online stores. SA has only one store that sells downloadable music through the Internet, Musica, in operation since December 2004. It has close to 800 000 songs on offer at around R9,90 each and hopes to have 1m songs in stock before Christmas.
In other parts of the world, digitial music stores are growing; an estimated 230 sites are running globally. The majority of these stores are in Europe.
Music industry analyst Jupiter says revenues from digital music reached $330m in 2004 and are forecast to more than double this year. Musica, for competitive reasons, does not want to say how much it is making on Internet sales . IFPI says music fans downloaded well over 200m tracks in 2004 in the US and Europe – 10 times more than in 2003. It further estimates that by 2009, online revenues will account for 25% of total global music sales .
Pino de Benedetto, with the SA operation of EMI, says local recording companies have identified the online market . "We need someone to sell the music digitally and legally. Otherwise illegal downloading will become an even bigger problem ," says De Benedetto. "But downloading is still in its infancy in SA and people are only now starting to experience it. Also, broadband access is slow and expensive ."
Haarburger says the industry also needs to move quickly to provide solutions to the mobile phone industry, which is demanding more music and video downloads for its users. "Soon we will have artists doing tracks just for the mobile sector. And we will also need to develop separate music videos for mobile phones," says Haarburger.
The uptake of 3G mobile systems will accelerate the trend. In the UK, Hutchison 3G, which runs the country’s largest video mobile network, last week said that more than 10m music videos had been watched by its customers.
While all these technological developments are good revenue generators for record companies and artists, protecting copyright and intellectual property is just another problem the industry faces .
Inet-Bridge || Discuss this article