How useful is ICASA?
ADSL Regulations
The recently released ADSL Regulations drew sharp criticism from many quarters regarding the lack of clarity and the unreasonable demands on ISPs.
Despite numerous requests – both oral and written submissions – that ICASA should deliver a clear and unambiguous set of ADSL regulations, it Gazetted a watered down version of the ADSL Draft Regulations, leaving various loopholes and great uncertainty.
What industry and consumers desperately needed after this release was clarity from the Regulator stipulating what is required from Telkom and ISPs including a time frame for implementing the new regulations.
ICASA is however very quiet. Numerous calls to the regulator and even questions in public forums like iWeek did little to shed light on the issue.
The two and a half year process in which various organizations and companies participated therefore culminated in a set of regulations that will mostly be ignored by industry and will do little to improve the pricing or service of ADSL in South Africa.
General trend
This is however not a secluded event.
At recent conferences ICASA openly invited industry and consumers to give their input and assist the regulator in its policy and regulation processes.
This request may however be nothing more than lip service as many delegates at these events pointed out that it is just about impossible to get hold of anybody at ICASA. What about actually being heard?
iWeek recently reported that industry players highlighted that the problem was not industry’s reluctance to contribute, but rather that ICASA is not interested in creating an effective communication channel.
In MyADSL’s experience it has proven far more effective trying to approach an ICASA councilor for comment at a public event than trying to contact the ICASA offices.
This raises the question as to how effective ICASA is in fulfilling its mandate to ‘protect consumers from unfair business practices, poor quality services and harmful or inferior products.’
The Authority is still milling over what to do regarding the high mobile rates in South Africa. It was ineffective in reducing the exorbitant pricing of ADSL in South Africa and not much seems to be happening to address the high bandwidth rates.
Paris Mashile, the ICASA Chairman, has however recently given his views on the issue of ADSL provisioning in South Africa.
Business Day reported that the lack of action from ICASA regarding the price of ADSL was due to a lack of evidence that Telkom is charging too much for ADSL. This statement is strange indeed since it was established at the ADSL hearings that local ADSL prices are around 1000% higher than international standards.
The two Department of Communications’ colloquiums held last year reaffirmed evidence stating that the cost of telecommunications – and broadband in specific – in South Africa is far higher than our overseas competitors.
Open it up
The solution to the problems is not easy, but it raises the question as to whether it will not be better just to open the telecoms arena up for competition and let the chips fall where they may.
ICASA can use its rather limited resources to manage issues like spectrum allocation, leaving market forces to decide the fate of telecoms companies.
This will however mean that companies like Telkom and Neotel’s profits may shrink, something that Government, which has a large stake in both these companies, does not want to see.
It is therefore very unlikely that we will see a truly liberalized telecoms environment anytime soon, and we may just have to hope that ICASA gets more funding, that it is given true independence and that the few competent senior staff left do not also depart in search of greener pastures.