Technology7.12.2006

Where do you look for value in cellphone operators?

This single number allows one to compare apples with apples, network A with network B. ARPU is exactly that: the average revenue generated by a cellphone subscriber (contract or prepaid) during a specific reporting period. ARPU figures take into account voice, data and related revenue from a user during a month.

In South Africa though, we seem to have invented a beast known as the “blended ARPU” – which when used within earshot of non-tech savvy people, makes one seem even more intelligent. It’s a fancy term, for rather boring data. Prepaid customers spend far less per month than contract (postpaid) subscribers. The blended figure provides an overall average across all subscribers.

This is where the balancing act comes in: you need to watch your ratio of postpaid to prepaid users. If you have a huge amount of customers each generating revenue of R10 every month versus a tiny portion spending over R600, you have a problem. Not the best business situation to be in.

Growth at any cost

A while ago, a colleague mentioned that someone in the motor industry told him that it was easy to sell a lot of luxury cars. Sales records are easy to break: all you do is discount the cars to hell and back. Done.

Simalalrly it’s (relatively) easy to sign up subscribers. How you make money off them is another question entirely.

Cellphone companies need to get you to spend more per month. They need you to send more SMSs, use more data services, make more calls, and then they need to get you to migrate from a prepaid option to a postpaid one. The annuity income (monthly subscription) is locked in, and typically you’ll spend a lot more on the phone – there’s no need to recharge, the debit order takes care of the billing and you don’t give the cost of making a call a second thought.

Saturation

We’re all aware that the cellphone subscriber market in South Africa is reaching saturation. How many people do you know without a cellphone?

Consequently, cellphone networks are beginning to target low-income earners to boost subscriber numbers. Everyone in the middle-to-upper-end of the market has a phone – some have two, three, four – and growth will come from the so-called mass market.

But – and it’s a big “but” – larger numbers of low-income earners means your ARPU comes right down.

The tale of two networks

An ARPU comparison between Vodacom and MTN’s operations in South Africa is very telling. The two networks seem very similar. They started at roughly the same time, are much bigger than Cell C, and offer –similar services. They also spend millions on advertising each year, fighting for the disillusioned customers looking to switch networks. Most people know that Vodacom is bigger in terms of subscriber numbers (and revenue), but is bigger better?

A look at Vodacom’s ARPU over the past five years tells a very different story to that of MTN’s. While contract (postpaid) ARPUs are fairly comparable across the two networks (in the R600 to R500 region), Vodacom’s prepaid ARPUs are rather startling. The number has fallen dramatically from the R90 level to a little over R60 now. This has the effect of pulling Vodacom’s blended ARPU down, which doesn’t help the situation.

In an attempt to help make these numbers look better, Vodacom announced an unusual plan earlier this year. In essence, it was going to cut off 3m subscribers from its network, and what great headlines that piece of information made. The truth is somewhat more low-key. Vodacom was sitting with a problem: 3m people were sitting on its network, being counted as active subscribers but these people were using their sim cards to retrieve voicemail – in effect spending less than R1 a month.

Vodacom said it was costing more to keep them active than to have them as subscribers. It was hoped this would also boost Vodacom’s prepaid ARPU (divide revenue by 14m instead of 17m customers and you’ll see a vast difference). At the time of the announcement, Vodacom noted that this would have the desired effect: “The impact of the activity rule change will have an immaterial impact on revenue, but it would have the effect of increasing prepaid ARPU for the period.”

Analysts and others hoped the effects of this would be seen in the Vodacom interim numbers (to end September), but prepaid ARPU decreased further! Vodacom gave the following reason: “The continued dilution of ARPU is caused by the higher proportion of lower ARPU connections as the lower-end of the market is penetrated.”

Admittedly, the process of cutting off these subscribers will only be complete at the end of this month, and one hopes we’ll see improvements.

By contrast, MTN’s prepaid ARPU has stayed within the R11 range since 2002 (from R105 to R94). This seems to be largely the result of MTN not aggressively chasing growth in subscriber numbers. MTN has admitted, at every opportunity, that while growth is important, it is focusing on retaining customers, keeping those subscribers happy and getting users to spend more. The results could not be clearer.

Internationally

European cellphone operators have it toughest of all, when trying to boost subscribers. The market is saturated and hence what they try to do is boost ARPU – getting customers to spend more time talking, send more SMSs, download more video clips, browse more websites.

The blended ARPUs for European operations are at the R200+ level. Vodafone’s ARPU is almost R300! Contrast this with Vodafone’s Africa, Middle East and Asia businesses which sits at R 56.

Chasing rands

Its clear that the two large operators in SA have different strategies to grow revenue. One aims to get a bulk of subscribers (suffer a bit in the short term) and then figure out ways to grow revenue. The other, while still aiming to grow the subscriber base, is already making a lot of money per user. The challenges for the rest of Africa are similar.

For now the one looks a lot better on paper. Which one is your money on?

Discuss this article

Show comments

Latest news

More news

Trending news

Poll

If money was no issue, which brand of smartphone would you buy?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter