Mobile data issues
With the lack of fixed line infrastructure in many countries and even in rural areas of South Africa, the evolution of cellular communication was the logical alternative. Cellphones are today the most used communication instrument , but what about mobile data communication? Will 3G and high speed packet access (HSPA) be able to compete with WiMAX?
While WiMAX is the Johnny-come-lately, many telecommunication industry commentators believe that WiMAX will become the technology of choice. They base their arguments on the fact that while there is already so much cellular data-handling infrastructure, there are very few customers.
Traditionally 3G and HSPA were expensive. With high capital investment in networks, cellular providers had to do something to grow their data customer base hence the massive price reductions we have seen in recent weeks. Vodacom cut mobile high speed data rates by up to 61%.
Whether a customer has a 3G or 3G HSDPA data contract, they can now surf the internet for under 19c per megabyte. Two years ago, mobile data users were paying R40 per Meg. Then there is the other side of the coin. Can cellular communication take over from traditional mobile radio? Is the industry working silos? Pushing for their technologies? These are difficult questions to answers and elicit diverse responses.
Robert Wuestenenk, senior manager: broadband networks for Ericsson’s market unit sub-Saharan Africa says that mobile broadband is the natural evolution of mobile data services and offers both fixed and mobile operators tremendous opportunities. As HSPA spreads worldwide and laptops start shipping with embedded 3G modems, he notes that it is time for African operators to start preparing for this.
“There is very little doubt that the internet is going mobile.” It’s a move that he believes fixed and mobile operators alike should welcome. “It will add important new revenue streams alongside existing ones.
“The convergence of the internet and mobile telephony is an inevitable step,” says Wuestenenk, “we remain enthusiastic about making our vision of an all-communicating world a reality in Africa too.” But is mobile broadband a viable option for Africa? That is the burning question.
As HSPA spreads worldwide the number of successful deployments of mobile broadband worldwide continues to grow, but is it a viable option for Africa? Mobile broadband is typically associated with advanced, data-intensive users in developed or formal economies. Wuestenenk believes that it could play an important role in bridging the ‘digital divide’ in Africa as well.
“Mobile networks weren’t able to provide the bit rates expected at first but 3G has closed that gap and provides the kind of ‘available everywhere’ high-speed internet access that users are looking for. As Deutsche Bank Securities recently acknowledged, it makes sense to leverage the mobile phone and 3GSM as the technology for ICT in Africa. Copper is just not viable, particularly given the vast, predominantly rural, areas that need covering.”
Is the security industry another customer for cellular data service providers?
Enhanced security including remote video surveillance has become a major initiative for many organisations and individuals. Radio 702 listeners were recently bombarded with advertising for a security camera system that calls one’s cellphone and sends images from the camera. It opens up a whole new series of applications. Perhaps the break the cellular data providers have been waiting for.
Commercial high-resolution video cameras used for real-time surveillance require a reliable high speed IP connection to the control centre. The option to use readily available copper or fibre connections is not feasible for many situations where a video surveillance system needs to be set up immediately. According to Sadiq Malik of Broadband Communication Technologies (BCT Global) in any digital video networked solution the number one barrier to overcome is the transport part of the application, namely, bandwidth: which could be the most expensive part of the cost. Is this a candidate for 3G and HSPA?
Voice over data
With the reduced cost of mobile data, the question of VoIP arises. Here is an innovative opportunity to provide VoIP services to replace cellular voice at a dramatically lower rate. One of the cellular providers doesn’t allow VoIP over their data network; another one declined to comment. It is clearly a hot potato!
There is still a case for traditional mobile radio!
Noel Watermeyer of Alcom Matomo says that it would appear that the current broadband technologies development focus is squarely in the high volume market where the majority of users are content with the time taken to dial a number and set up the call or, possibly unknowingly, be subjected to disrupted or uncertain voice communication, especially in a ‘group’ call set-up. As such there does not seem to be any significant drive by broadband technologies to fulfil the stringent requirements of a professional radio user whose dominant need still remains instantaneous and guaranteed group-oriented voice communication.
The GSM derived technologies seem to position themselves somewhere between the two. Not entirely matching either technology in the environment for which it has been developed. The proponents of Tetra (see page 14) recognise the increasing need of their clients to also have higher data transfer capability available and as such are developing mechanisms to increase this capability – Tetra II. Although this does not seem as though it will ever match the dedicated data throughput of the broadband technologies, the negative financial and logistical practicalities of privately deploying broadband with its – relative to Tetra – limited range, currently still outweigh the restrictions of data throughput.
“There can be no compromise of the voice and feature requirements of the professional radio user. We do not have a converged technology that will satisfy the needs of all user groups, yet”, Watermeyer said. No doubt we will see some interesting developments as the communication industry continues the convergence process. Time will tell.