Cellular19.09.2007

“Passive income” scheme disappoints

Investors who bought licences in a rewards scheme called Freetalk are seeking legal redress. They claim they were sold the licences under false pretences.

Meanwhile, Freetalk argues that the reason for their failure is that they have not worked hard enough at their businesses.

Whatever the reason, the Freetalk business does not seem to be a resounding success. Moneyweb does not know a single person who makes use of its rewards programme, and we have yet to talk to a licencee who is not bitter about his or her purchase. We invite successful licencees to contact us.

Simply, Freetalk offers its licencees the prospect of earning a "passive income" by selling a rewards programme to clients. Clients earn "free" cellular airtime by swiping their Freetalk card at "participating partners". Licencees earn commission on each transaction.

Freetalk claims to have in excess of 1 200 retail partners. The list can be viewed at its website: http://www.freetalk.bz/.

These partners are mostly small shops, scattered around the country. Tellingly, Freetalk does not have any of the major retail chains signed up, such as Pick ‘n Pay (JSE: PIK), Shoprite (JSE:SHP), Massmart (JSE:MSM), Ellerines (JSE:ELH) and JD Group (JSE:JDG).

Freetalk has sold 56 licences to investors around the country. Some licences cost more than R1m, but most were sold for about a quarter of a million rand. Freetalk CEO Theuns Schoeman has declined to tell Moneyweb exactly how much money has been invested into licences.

One licencee, who declines to be named for fear of victimisation, says he bought his licence for R225 000 on the strength of MTN's involvement in the scheme.

Freetalk has wholesaler and dealer contracts with MTN. This allows it to market MTN's prepaid, postpaid and banking products.

It was also provisionally appointed as an MTN rewards partner, provided certain contitions were met within a set period. During this period, Freetalk referred to itself as an "official MTN rewards partner".

"Not all conditions were met at the due date and as such the provisional appointment lapsed which led to Freetalk not being able to be referred to as an MTN rewards partner anymore," says MTN senior manager: customer satisfaction Jacques Hattingh.

However, Hattingh says that some of the people Freetalk employed "opted not to adhere to this request."

Potential investors in Freetalk licences should bear in mind that Schoeman's history is not spotless. Earlier this year Rapport noted that in 1999, both Old Mutual and Sanlam ended their brokers' contracts with him.

Rapport said that Schoemans's sequestration shortly afterwards had to do with the sales of policies that didn't exist, for which insurance companies paid him commissions.

Freetalk agent Kevin Cholwich, who represents Freetalk-related companies U Talk Mobile and Resultfin, has skeletons in his own closet. He features in a Sunday Tribune story as the owner of Johennesburg-based Concept Brokers, which offered investors a "genuine opportunity of a lifetime" to get a return of R6m within three years, for each investment of R250 000. Claims were made that the medical device he was selling, a patented radiowave transmitter, cured Aids, cancer, Alzheimer's Disease, and even the common cold, Sunday Tribune reported.

Comments

 

Show comments

Latest news

More news

Trending news

Poll

If money was no issue, which brand of smartphone would you buy?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter