MTN fires warning shot at Cell C
MTN notified shareholders on Monday morning that its South African business had failed to reach an agreement with Cell C on “certain matters” in their long-standing commercial relationship.
Cell C no longer operates its own radio access network (RAN) and relies heavily on MTN to serve its customers.
In November 2018, Cell C and MTN signed a national roaming agreement which gave Cell C access to MTN’s 3G and 4G networks.
That agreement was expanded in August 2019, which enabled Cell C to shut down its radio network and move all its traffic onto a virtual network operated by MTN.
The virtual RAN differs from a standard roaming agreement in that it uses Cell C’s assigned radio frequency spectrum and provides access to MTN’s cellular network resources.
Later, Cell C also granted MTN access to some of its frequencies as part of a spectrum-pooling agreement, which the sector regulator, ICASA, approved in 2022.
Therefore, in addition to benefiting commercially from the arrangement, MTN also gained access to some of Cell C’s spectrum capacity.
Both operators’ networks benefitted substantially from the partnership. MyBroadband Insights’ quarterly network quality reports showed significant and consistent gains for MTN and Cell C.
This has been a major boon for Cell C, which had a reputation for having South Africa’s cheap, low-quality network.
That is no longer the case, as Cell C can now provide comparable network quality to Vodacom and MTN. Cell C also has a roaming agreement with Vodacom, which is primarily used by its contract customers.
The drawback of this arrangement is that Cell C is dependent on Vodacom and MTN, which weakens its negotiating position.
Cell C CEO Jorge Mendes previously said he was not worried about losing the wholesale agreements or price gouging, as the deals also benefit Vodacom and MTN.
However, given that MTN has taken the unusual step of publicising its dispute with Cell C in a quarterly trading statement released on the JSE News Service, the partnership has hit a snag.
“MTN SA and Cell C have engaged extensively on the terms of their long-standing commercial relationship but have not reached agreement on certain matters,” it said.
“These will be addressed through the mechanisms provided for in the parties’ agreement, while engagement on the terms of the relationship going forward continues.”
MTN did not indicate which parts of its commercial relationship with Cell C were in dispute, but its statement was a clear warning to Cell C. MTN said it would provide a further update when appropriate.