The SABC’s requirement to reply to the public protector’s report on its then acting chief operations officer Hlaudi Motsoeneng was unrelated to his permanent appointment, the public broadcaster said.
“The public protector has nothing to do with this [permanent appointment of Motsoeneng],” SABC spokesman Kaizer Kganyago told Sapa.
“The two are not together… I don’t know how the two are related.”
Kganyago said any attempt to draw inferences about Motsoeneng’s appointment from the report were subjective.
“You read what you want to read.”
He said Madonsela’s report stipulated only that the COO position had to be filled; not who should fill it.
On Wednesday, 9 July 2014, Public Protector Thuli Madonsela expressed her surprise at Motsoeneng’s appointment.
“I’m still waiting for a response from the SABC and from the minister; until then I’m not in a position to understand what has just happened,” Madonsela told SABC radio news.
Communications Minister Faith Muthambi announced Motsoeneng’s appointment in Pretoria on Tuesday night, saying she had made the appointment following a recommendation by the SABC board.
In February, Madonsela released a report which found Motsoeneng’s SABC appointment irregular.
At the time of releasing her report, Madonsela recommended that a new COO be appointed within 90 days. This deadline has since elapsed.
After a previous request for extra time, the SABC board was given until August 17 to respond to Madonsela’s report.
On Wednesday, Madonsela said she had had no response from either the communications department or the SABC.
Kganyago declined to say when a reply to the protector would be issued, only that it would occur when the board finalised its response.
In an SABC statement on Wednesday, Kganyago said the broadcaster was pleased to announce the COO position had been filled. He said the minister had “applied her mind” to the board’s recommendation in appointing Motsoeneng.
In the statement, SABC board chairwoman Ellen Tshabalala was quoted as saying the appointment would help move the organisation forward. Tshabalala said “further stability” was being created.
The SA Communist Party said Motsoeneng’s appointment was concerning.
“The appointment of Mr Motsoeneng constitutes gross disregard of a series of investigations and audits into the SABC relating to governance and administration,” spokesman Alex Mashilo said in a statement.
The SACP called on Muthambi to review her decision to appoint him permanently.
“The SACP holds the board accountable for its actions which amount to misleading the minister, who should have been given sufficient information and all relevant reports to apply her mind thoroughly.”
Lobby group AfriForum said the appointment indicated the SABC board had “refrained from heeding” the Public Protector’s earlier proposals.
Deputy CEO Alana Bailey said in a statement the move was “a further example of disrespect for the Constitution and constitutional institutions that exist to protect the public against abuse of power and mismanagement”.
The EFF was “distraught” by Motsoeneng’s appointment.
“Motsoeneng does not deserve to be COO, because he is a liar and a conman,” Economic Freedom Fighters’ spokesman Mbuyiseni Ndlozi said in a statement.
Ndlozi said the decision to appoint Motsoeneng raised concerns about Muthambi’s capabilities.
He said the EFF would take the matter to court.
Last week, political parties called for Motsoeneng to be relieved of his duties. This was after Motsoeneng suggested journalists should have a licence to practice, as in the medical and law professions.
Also last week, Motsoeneng appeared before Parliament to present a strategic plan and budget for the SABC, which received a disclaimer of opinion from the Auditor General — the most adverse finding he can make.
Parliament heard the SABC was losing advertisers and viewers.
In Madonsela’s report issued in February, she found Motsoeneng’s salary increased from R1.5 million to R2.4m in one year, that he had purged senior staff, and misrepresented his qualifications – that he passed matric – to the SABC.