Internet5.05.2008

High-tech highwaymen

If you had to get your hands on money and didn't care much about the law, where would you go? Fort Knox? A bank?

Since forever, criminals have focused not on where money is well-protected, but where it is in transit. Medieval highwaymen were no different from stage coach robbers, and they have their modern counterparts in cash-in-transit hijackers.

All these methods, however, have a major drawback. All pose significant risks to the thief.

Alternatives developed by organised crime groups, such as operating brothels, drug trafficking or Ponzi schemes, may improve the returns, and reduce the chances of getting caught, but still you risk opening your door only to face a policeman with a gun, intent on ruining your day.

Online crime simply follows this trend. Where money is in transit, it is vulnerable. And where the risk to the criminal is lowest is where the criminal is going to go.

Sanjay Bavisi, co-founder and president of the EC-Council, explains: “In the 1980s, a hacker was someone who wanted to prove their worth and the motivation was fame. Now, the motivation is far more about making money. It could be corporate espionage, or organised crime. The script kiddie will always exist, but the scale is moving towards where the money is. There's more money in organised cybercrime than there is in drugs, according to a report I read recently, and many cartels are switching away from drugs, because the risk is less and the capital is lower, and it's almost anonymous. You don't have to stand in the line of fire.”

For similar reasons, a growing trend in international espionage and warfare is to risk fewer bodies on the streets and battlefields, and rely more on what McAfee's 2007 Virtual Criminology report calls “cyber cold war”.

As more ready-made tools become available, and more people transact and communicate online, the value proposition for industrial espionage, organised crime, and intelligence and counter-intelligence, becomes increasingly favourable.

It's not limited to notorious countries, such as Russia or Nigeria, where cyber-crime flourishes. Renaud Bidou, a security specialist at Radware, who works mainly in European countries, says, “I have seen cases of extorsion, hacktivism, scams, industrial cybercrime almost anywhere in Europe. Countries such as Russia and China are just scapegoats.”

German foreign minister Joschka Fischer recently estimated the scale of cyber-crime at $40 billion a year. Average annual reported losses for US companies doubled in 2007, from less than $170 000 to over $350 000. And that's just what they dare to report.

As Bidou says, most victims won't complain, either because they don't want their story to become public or because they don't even realise they have been abused. Worse, most revenue generated by cyber-crime is not simple trade of goods or services. “When a spam campaign leads to a noticeable impact on the price of a share, for example, it becomes harder to estimate how much money has been generated. Same thing when a denial of service campaign leads customers to change their service provider.”

Bidou agrees that the industry is little different from any other industry, or any other organised crime. In the end, the attack methods must be efficient enough and hard enough to stop, and the money that is obtained needs to be laundered, where it might be interdicted by financial fraud investigators.

“The strength of botnets is their size,” says Bidou.

“The best way to reduce their efficiency is to starve them, by reducing their capability to propagate, by interrupting communications between the bots and the master, by educating users so that they don't get infected so easily. In the end, if the complexity to build and operate an efficient botnet gets too high, in relation to limited revenue and increased difficulty to reinject cybercrime money into the legal financial world, then the whole system will collapse.”

Bidou and Bavisi will be among the many presenters at ITWeb's Security Summit 2008, to be held from 6-8 May at Vodaworld, Midrand

 

Show comments

Latest news

More news

Trending news

Poll

Which company do you trust the most for an ERP system?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter