Edward Snowden says he repeatedly raised constitutional concerns about U.S. National Security Agency surveillance internally, but an NSA search turned up a single email in which Snowden asks for “clarification” on a technical legal question about training materials, agency officials said Thursday.
Snowden, a former NSA systems administrator whose leaks have exposed some of the agency’s most sensitive spying operations, called himself a patriot in an interview this week with NBC. He said he felt he had no choice but to expose what he considered illegal NSA surveillance by leaking secret details to journalists.
NSA officials have said Snowden gained access to some 1.7 million classified documents, though it’s not clear how many he removed from the Hawaii facility where he worked as a contractor.
Asked by Williams whether he first raised his concerns with his bosses, Snowden said, “I reported that there were real problems with the way the NSA was interpreting its legal authorities.”
On Thursday, NSA released the email they said Snowden appeared to be referring to, which the agency says is the only communication from Snowden it could find raising any concerns. It was dated April 8, 2013, three months after Snowden first reached out to journalists anonymously. Former NSA chief Gen. Keith Alexander said the agency could find no one to whom Snowden voiced concerns in person, either.
In the email to NSA’s general counsel’s office, Snowden questions an NSA document showing the hierarchy of governing authorities, which appeared to put executive orders on par with federal statutes.
“I’m not entirely certain, but this does not seem correct, as it seems to imply executive orders have the same precedence as law,” Snowden said in the email. “Could you please clarify?”
An unidentified NSA lawyer began his reply, “Hello, Ed,” and told Snowden he was correct: Executive orders cannot override federal law.
In the NBC interview – conducted in Moscow, where Snowden now lives outside the reach of pending U.S. criminal charges – Snowden said the reply he got to his email was “more or less, in bureaucratic language, ‘You should stop asking questions.'”
In fact, the lawyer’s email to him concludes, “Please give me a call if you would like to discuss further.”
No specific surveillance program was discussed in the email.
The Obama administration changed the surveillance programs after public outcry as a result of the classified material Snowden gave to journalists.
But U.S. officials say Snowden’s assertions that he repeatedly tried to raise concerns internally before choosing to leak are not accurate.
“There were and there are numerous avenues that Mr. Snowden could have used to raise other concerns or whistle-blower allegations,” White House spokesman Jay Carney said Thursday. ”
Snowden also said he was trained as an undercover spy, an allegation that national security adviser Susan Rice denied.
American Civil Liberties Union lawyer Ben Wizner, Snowden’s legal adviser, insisted Snowden “raised many complaints over many channels.”
Wizner added, “The problem was not some unknown and isolated instance of misconduct. The problem was that an entire system of mass surveillance had been deployed – and deemed legal – without the knowledge or consent of the public.”