THE SQUEEZE BEGINS
Faced with three wireless rivals – Sentech (with MyWireless), Wireless Business Solutions (iBurst) and Vodacom (3G) – and the prospect of more competition from MTN and the still-to-be-named second network operator, Telkom has cut its prices and introduced a new, entry-level broadband solution. Two of the more important announcements from Telkom are:
* The introduction of HomeDSL 192 – this new 192 Kbit/s downstream, always-on service will cost R329/month (excluding phone-line rental and Internet service provider charges, which will double that number).
* Price cuts to HomeDSL 512 – this, currently the fastest Telkom asymmetric digital subscriber line (ADSL) service, has been reduced in price by 12% to R599/month (excluding additional fees). A similar offering, but for business, falls to R699/month from R800. Both the home and business packages include limited free access to Telkom’s Wi-Fi wireless broadband hotspots located in hotels, airports, shopping centres and conference venues.
The price of Telkom’s midtier product, HomeDSL 384, remains unchanged at R449/month (again excluding additional charges).
The 512 Kbit/s price cuts and the introduction of a cheaper but slower
192 Kbit/s option are good news for consumers, though SA broadband users still pay among the highest fees in the world for their connections.
Telkom CEO Sizwe Nxasana defends the prices. "People compare us with countries that are at a different stage of development than we are," he says. "But we are catching up very quickly."
He won’t admit it but the "catching up" that he refers to has little to do with SA’s economic development or size relative to other countries and everything to do with a lack of competition. Egyptians, for example, have access to 512 Kbit/s ADSL for only R250/month. In Germany, broadband Internet access is available for as little as R31/month. Even after the price cuts, a 512 Kbit/s package from Telkom costs nearly four times as much as it does in Egypt and includes restrictions such as a 3 GB monthly usage cap .
Competitors such as Wireless Business Solutions (WBS) and Sentech haven’t entered the market with significantly lower prices, either. They can’t because they have to deploy new wireless networks, whereas the fixed-line network is already largely a sunk cost for Telkom. Also, these rivals have to purchase most, if not all, of their international bandwidth from Telkom. With the exception of some inherently expensive and slower satellite links operated by Sentech, Telkom has a monopoly in this area. The prices it charges for access to international telecom circuits are way higher than what it would be able to charge in a competitive environment.
Telkom’s high prices even drew fire from President Thabo Mbeki in his state of the nation address to parliament last month. Mbeki described the "situation in which some of our fixed-line rates are 10 times those of developed countries" as "unacceptable".
Nxasana denies Telkom’s decision to cut its broadband prices was made under pressure from government or as a result of Mbeki’s speech. "[The president’s] comment was in the context of liberalisation [and] we laud government for opening the market [to competition]."
Telkom chief sales and marketing officer Nombulelo Moholi says Telkom has recognised it can grow the market by cutting prices. She says Telkom will reduce its broadband prices again once "economies of scale" allow it. "As more people adopt ADSL, so prices will drop."
If history is any lesson, though, it is competitive pressure alone that will force prices down. Sentech, the state-owned broadcast signal distributor and Internet provider, says Telkom’s price cuts are in direct response to competition from wireless operators, including Sentech.
Sentech marketing and sales executive Marcel Raath says his company will introduce new products in the next three months as it seeks to fend off Telkom’s new packages and prices. Though it won’t cut the prices of its existing products – at least not yet – Sentech will introduce new and cheaper, but slower, packages at the low end, as well as faster but more expensive options for people who require more bandwidth.
Wireless rivals have a long way to catch up to Telkom, which now has 50 000 ADSL customers. Sentech has only 4 000 customers using MyWireless, which is significantly fewer than it was hoping for at launch a year ago. The launch was badly executed and left customers fuming about network speeds and poor service. Though it has since solved many of these problems, it has a poor reputation.
WBS, which says it has learnt lessons from Sentech’s mistakes, will launch commercially within the next few weeks. Telkom executives say privately that they view WBS as more of a competitive threat than Sentech.
Telkom is not taking the threat from the wireless operators lying down.
Apart from its price cuts, it is piloting its own wireless network using technology based on the nascent WiMax standard, one of the first operators in the world to do so. It won’t say when it will offer this network commercially but it’s unlikely to be this year . The technology for the trial is being supplied by US wireless broadband equipment maker Alvarion.
Telkom has also begun deploying a technology called very high-speed DSL
(VDSL) – which offers access speeds of up to 52 Mbit/s – in residential complexes. Though VDSL is limited by the 1 km distance consumers have to be from the telephone exchange, it is an ideal high-speed option for office parks, secure residential villages and high-rise apartment blocks.
Other ADSL products are in the pipeline, including a top-end 1 Mbit/s option aimed at business users. Pricing for this package must still be determined.
Reproduced with the permission of the Financial Mail.