Technology30.03.2005

UNDER SIEGE


In an unprecedented move, some of Telkom’s broadband clients –
subscribers to its asymmetric digital subscriber line (ADSL) service –
are mounting a campaign against the monopoly operator. They have become
increasingly vociferous in recent months, voicing their frustration on
a website forum.

The quality and high level of debate on the website, MyADSL.co.za, is
unlike any consumer lobby group to have emerged in SA. The site is read
by a number of industry executives.

Members of the website’s forum have successfully lobbied the
Independent Communications Authority of SA (Icasa), which has called
special hearings later this month to hear their complaints.

According to a draft programme for the hearings, 27 individuals will
make oral presentations over the course of four days in mid-April.
Telkom, MTN Network Solutions, Internet Solutions and the Internet
Society will also make presentations.

The voice of consumer activism against Telkom has also been heard in
KwaZulu Natal, where a Pietermaritzburg-based newspaper, The Witness,
has taken up the cudgels for customers angry with a new service being
offered by the company. In an article published on March 19, the
newspaper alleged that Telkom had found a way of "duping its customers"
by installing a "free" basic voicemail service without first seeking
customers’ consent.

According to The Witness, this basic voicemail service kicks in after
seven rings, or immediately if the line is engaged. Though this doesn’t
cost the person using the service anything, the calling party pays the
cost of the telephone call as soon as the voicemail message starts.

"In this way, Telkom is able to convert almost all unconnected calls on
Telkom lines to chargeable, connected’ calls. It aims to make a fortune
off its customers in the process," the newspaper reported, adding that
Icasa was investigating the claims.

The regulatory and consumer pressures come amid mounting evidence that
Telkom’s relationship with government – which still holds 38% of the
company’s equity – is not as good as it once was.

Government is keen to see the company reduce its prices. President
Thabo Mbeki, in his state of the nation address to parliament in
February, described SA’s high fixed-line telecom costs as
"unacceptable".

Government’s seriousness about bringing down costs is clear from its
bid to tackle Telkom’s monopoly on access to the submarine telecom
cables that link SA with the rest of the world.

Government has asked Icasa to consider declaring the cables an
"essential service" (see FM Focus March 18). Internet service providers
say Telkom is charging them exorbitant rates for access to the
bandwidth on these cables and that this is keeping the cost of Internet
access in SA artificially high.

If Icasa decides it can’t use regulations to declare the cables an
essential service, government says it would consider writing a clause
into the Convergence Bill, new legislation that is due to replace the
Telecommunications Act this year, to force Telkom to sell access to the
cables at wholesale prices.

Telkom has objected strongly to government’s plans, saying it could
jeopardise investments the company was planning to make in other
submarine projects, including one to build a cable up the east coast of
Africa.

In a development that is likely to strain relations further, Telkom CEO
Sizwe Nxasana warned last week that the company planned to increase the
cost of already expensive local telephone calls to compensate for the
need to cut prices in areas where the company faced competition, such
as in international service.

Nxasana was quoted in press reports as saying that Telkom "will have to
increase the price of local calls gradually over a considerable time".
He added: "The cost of maintaining the last mile link [this is the
component of the fixed-line network that links consumers to their local
telephone exchange] is very high."

These comments aren’t likely to sit well with government or the
regulator, given that price increases in local calls will hit the poor
the hardest.

Telkom’s comments come as Icasa is drawing up new regulations that
propose introducing stricter limits on its ability to increase the cost
of telephony. This would constrain the company’s ability to engage in
cross-subsidisation between local and international services.

But perhaps the biggest threat facing Telkom is the prospect of real
competition. Not only is it facing opposition from Internet companies
that can now legally offer voice telephony, but the second network
operator is also likely – finally – to begin offering services later
this year.

Also, government says the Convergence Bill, when it is enacted, will
allow Internet service providers to build their own wireless networks
to serve their clients directly. Specific broadband licences could also
be issued. All these factors are likely to exert strong downward
pressure on prices over the next few years.

Neither consumers nor government may be particularly enamoured with
Telkom, but the company’s shareholders will be more than pleased with
its performance since its listing two years ago. Telkom’s high rates,
together with careful cost management, have helped the company produce
sparkling financial results – and a commensurate run-up in its share
price.

In its most recent six-month period, to September 2004, Telkom
increased headline earnings per share by 59,8% to R5,37. Net profit
rose 66,4% to R2,77bn.

Reproduced with the permission of the Financial Mail.

Original article: http://secure.financialmail.co.za/05/0401/technology/atech.htm

Show comments

Latest news

More news

Trending news

Poll

What is the download speed of your home Internet connection?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter