Telkom’s assertions rebutted
He said that with a limited range of products to choose from in a market dominated by the fixed-line operator, it was inevitable that Telkom’s three broadband offerings would be rated higher than those furnished by Sentech, Vodacom and WBS.
Freiman was speaking on the third of four days of public hearings into the price and quality of Telkom’s asymmetrical digital subscriber line (ADSL) services, being held at the Sandton offices of the telecommunications industry’s regulator, the Independent Communications Authority of South Africa (Icasa).
A nine-member panel of Icasa staffers, chaired by councillor Mamodupi Mohlala, has waded through 446 written submissions and is listening to 32 oral presentations on the matter, with individuals travelling to Gauteng from other provinces in order to air their views.
Keen not to be depicted as ‘anti-Telkomâ€, Rudolph Mulller, the founder of MyADSL who initially lodged the complaint, commenced his presentation by explaining the fixed-line operator had been approached to explain and justify its services on numerous occasions, but failed to respond: “Our intention is to help Telkom improve their ADSL services,†he said.
Muller labelled Telkom’s comparison of its services to those offered by the three wireless operators ‘ridiculous’, likening it to an attempt to classify cellular phones with fixed-line telephones. He said Sentech, WBS and Vodacom should be commended for bringing alternatives to the market: “They are being brave enough to complete with a very cheap, mature technology like ADSL,†he told the panel.
Regarding Telkom’s comments that 88% of its ADSL customers had expressed overall satisfaction in a Markinor survey, Muller said the results of that survey were never made public. However, a survey conducted by website ananzi.co.za showed that out of 721 people who voted, 83% said they were dissatisfied with the service, 10% were happy and 7% remained undecided.
Similarly, a poll run by MyADSL showed that out of 876 people who voted, 98% found the price of ADSL services in South Africa to be unfair.
ADSL ‘a privilege of the elite’
Both President Thabo Mbkei and the department of communications see bridging the digital divide as a crucial challenge that needs to be overcome if South Africa is to develop, said Muller. “Current ADSL pricing is does not address this, as connectivity consumes more than 50% of the average South African’s salary. This makes ADSL a privilege of the elite,†he said.
MTN NS’ Freiman said that at the rate of current deployment, it would take around ten years for 1% of the South African population to get broadband services. He adds that local Internet development is being hindered: â€Local Internet access has grown by only 10% over the last three years; local Internet transit comprised 53% of all traffic in January 2002 and 63% in April 2005. Internet in South Africa can reach world standards if we address local peering issues, quick access and costs.â€
A strangulated market
Both MTN Network Solutions and Dimension Data subsidiary Internet Solutions (IS) used the hearings as an opportunity to voice concerns about how Internet service providers (ISPs) obtain Internet connectivity.
Mark Furman, the legal head at IS, said the input costs incurred by ISPs make it impossible for them to compete effectively with Telkom, as current regulations mean that only the fixed-line operator can provide the necessary infrastructure. “ISPs can either obtain connectivity through Telkom’s IP Connect product, or by buying ADSL accounts from the Telkom-controlled South African Internet Exchange, SAIX. Because of the uncompetitive resale model, ISPs are prevented from adding reasonable margins and are thus unable to compete,†said Furman.
Illustrating the cost of local bandwidth, Geoff Rehmet, IS’ senior new business development consultant told Moneyweb a two megabit-per-second (Mbps) link between Johannesburg and Cape Town costs roughly the same as a 45Mbps link between New York and London.
Muller told the Icasa panel the wholesale price to ISPs for an account is R190; with Telkom selling accounts to customers at R218 a month, this leaves R28 for the ISP.
Although Telkom is also a value-added network service (Vans) provider, says Rehmet, that portion of its business does not feel the same pinch that other Vans providers do as there could be an element of cross-subsidisation: â€There is a lack of transparency within Telkom; it is not clear to what extent cross-subsidisation is taking place.â€
Problem solved
Muller proposes an end to the R600 monthly line rental charge, which is to pay for the port added to Telkom infrastructure to enable each ADSL line. “A port card is a once-off cost of between R300 to R600. At R600 month for connectivity rental; this means profits are made immediately after the first month,†he said.
He added that by ending this charge, ISPs like IS, UUNet, MTN NS and DataPro would be able to compete favourably with Telkom in an equal playing field.
IS’ Rehmet called for the R600 connection link to become part of the tariff basket which is regulated by Icasa.
The hearings continue on Monday; Telkom will be making a second presentation in response to some of the others.