Technology28.04.2005

A NUMBERS GAME

All three operators are going on the offensive ahead of the December 31 deadline because they believe they can gain market share if they play their cards right. MTN and Vodacom are both offering subscribers, especially bulk corporate subscribers, special deals in an attempt to entice them into contracts. Cellphone operators are lobbying for a system under which customers with 24-month contracts have to stay with the issuing network for the full period.

The introduction of number portability will increase churn in the industry as consumers switch to operators perceived to offer better value.

Despite his group having the most customers , Vodacom Group chief operating officer Pieter Uys says he views number portability as an opportunity to gain market share. "International case studies show that the impact of number portability is minimal and that operators offering the best quality and value benefit most."

Uys does not believe that pricing will play a big role in people’s choice of operator . Though he concedes Cell C had an initial advantage with its prices, this is no longer the case. "It is differentiation that counts now. That’s why we pushed BlackBerry and why we were the first to introduce 3G in SA."

Barry Gonin, GM in the office of the MD at MTN, concurs. "The networks that will win are those that have the best customer value offering. Price is only part of that value equation."

He says it is unlikely that the introduction of number portability will trigger a price war, though it is possible. "In markets with a high proportion of prepaid users (in SA it’s more than 85%), people exhibit low loyalty to the network, anyway," Gonin says. Also, switching operators won’t be free. The proposed regulations allow operators to charge up to R200 for the service.

Still, Peter Vella, the manager responsible for carrier relations at Cell C, says market research suggests his company will be a "net gainer" when number portability becomes effective. "People will be churning to us and we are also hoping for a [bigger] slice of the corporate action," he says.

But there’s a strong likelihood that the cellular operators will not meet the December 31 deadline, despite a legal obligation for them to do so. They say this is because of delays by the Independent Communications Authority of SA (Icasa) and the communications ministry in drafting and approving the regulations that will govern it.

The operators say this is holding them back from implementing the systems that will be needed to underpin the introduction of number portability.

Gonin says there is "massive concern" among the operators about whether the deadline can be met. "We don’t want to be lambasted as the wolf in this fairy tale and be blamed for the delay. We have engaged proactively and worked hard to get things done."

If the deadline is missed, it’ll be because the regulations have taken too long to be finalised. "I have sympathy for Icasa because it is dependent on the minister of communications to get things done," Gonin says. "It has put through the number portability regulations and a functional specification [this sets out the broad rules] to the minister and this appears to be where the process has got stuck."

The FM understands that one of the reasons for the delay is that the proposed number portability regulations conflict with the most recent draft of the Convergence Bill, proposed new legislation that will govern the sector. Gonin, who has read the bill, says it calls for number portability between all operators, fixed and mobile, whereas Icasa’s proposed regulations limit it to mobile-mobile and fixed-fixed networks (fixed-mobile and mobile-fixed is not contemplated). This is being dealt with by Icasa and the communications department in conjunction with the state law advisers.

Once the regulations have been promulgated, the operators will still be required to build a central database – at a shared cost of up to R50m . This database is needed because the three-digit prefix on a telephone number will no longer be sufficient in determining the network a subscriber uses.

Uys says it is not only the delay in the promulgation of the regulations that could hold up the process. He says there are also disagreements about how 24-month contracts should be handled. "Customers will be expected to honour their contracts before being allowed to port," he says. "We have invested in the network and the subscriber for the contractual period."

Procuring a database is also not easy, Uys says. "We are ready to do it and want to do it, but it normally takes months just to buy this sort of thing and it still has to be tested. "

If the operators fail to meet the December 31 deadline, they can each be fined (a relatively trivial) R500 000.

Reproduced with the permission of the Financial Mail

Original article: secure.financialmail.co.za/05/0429/technology/atech.htm

Show comments

Latest news

More news

Trending news

Poll

What is the download speed of your home Internet connection?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter