OFF TO A CAUTIOUS START
Karabotel is one of seven underserviced area licensee operators licensed to extend telecom services into areas poorly served by existing operators.
The licences have been granted in smaller towns and in rural areas. The operators plan to build networks in places as far flung as Ulundi, Nongoma, Vryheid, Welkom, Mafikeng, Polokwane, East London and Port Shepstone.
These areas have been identified because of their relatively low levels of teledensity. Incumbent operators, particularly Telkom, have preferred to focus most of their attention on the bigger urban centres, where returns are higher. Government and the sector regulator, the Independent Communications Authority of SA (Icasa), hope that the new operators will stimulate competition, reduce prices and raise teledensity.
Communications minister Ivy Matsepe-Casaburri says she hopes the local operators will act as a catalyst for economic development in the "second economy".
She may be hoping for too much. Karabotel is relatively advanced in its plans but some rural operators are struggling to convince potential funders, particularly the commercial banks, of their viability in the face of stiff competition from the cellular operators.
The rural players have each received R5m in initial funding from government’s universal service agency – with the promise of R10m more if they meet certain targets – but this is a drop in ocean next to the funding they will require if they are to build their own networks and compete effectively.
An industry executive who was involved with one of the operators but quit in frustration at delays is less optimistic. The executive, who asks not to be named, says some of the companies have spent more time fighting with each other in the boardroom than competing. Also, many lack the sales and marketing expertise needed to compete effectively with existing operators. "Why should you buy services from a start-up when you can get these from an incumbent?" he asks.
MTN and Vodacom pose the biggest challenge. The two will soon release a flood of free Simcards into the market as part of a deal with government. The agreement stipulates that in exchange for access to 1 800 MHz frequency spectrum, the two operators will provide 4m free Simcards to the poor.
Despite these challenges, Andre Wills, a telecom analyst and MD of consulting firm Africa Analysis, says he is "reasonably optimistic" about the companies’ prospects, but concedes they have a number of hurdles to overcome.
The only other country in Africa that has opened its market to "local-loop" competition to this extent is Nigeria, which has licensed a large number of fixed-wireless operators. "They [the local-loop operators] have targeted areas of high population density," Wills says. The underserviced area licensees, on the other hand, are specifically restricted from operating in the major urban centres. This is a big handicap.
"The challenge is coming up with a compelling value proposition," Wills says. "This will mean offering cheaper rates. But to do that, the operators must be very efficient."
They have several factors weighing in their favour which they need to take of advantage of, Wills says. Primary among these is number portability, where consumers can change their operator without losing their telephone number. This will be introduced next year. "The underserviced area operators could be the biggest beneficiaries of this," Wills says.
Most of the operators plan to begin offering services later this year. Even then, their offerings will be severely limited – most plan initially only to resell calls on Vodacom’s and MTN’s networks – while they seek funding to build their own networks.
Though they will eventually compete with the incumbent cellular providers, Vodacom has reached agreements with five of them: Kingdom Communications (based in Ulundi); B-Tel (Welkom); Karabotel (Mmabatho); Bokone Telecoms (Polokwane) and Amatole Telecoms (East London).
Vodacom will provide access to its network to these companies at a discount to its retail rates. The agreements are similar to a deal it struck with Cell C several years ago, which allows the cellular newcomer to use Vodacom’s network in areas where it hasn’t yet built base stations.
Vodacom’s involvement with the new operators will help it meet its empowerment requirements. But the cell operator also wants them to succeed because they have the potential to generate profits for the company. "Besides, either they come to us or they go to one of our competitors," says group chief operating officer Pieter Uys.
The support of Vodacom and MTN will give the new operators a much-needed leg-up. But ultimately they are expected to build their own networks.
Kingdom Communications, which has been licensed to operate a network in an arc extending across northern KwaZulu Natal, says potential funders, particularly the commercial banks, are "very reticent" to stump up cash. CEO Sifiso Mbata says the banks are worried the new operators do not have what it takes to compete with MTN and Vodacom, which already have coverage in many of the areas in which the new companies have been licensed to operate.
Karabotel’s Moyo agrees. He says SA’s banks are "very conservative" and that the new operators will have to prove that they have what it takes to succeed.
Moyo estimates that Karabotel will need about R60m to build its own network in its licence area, which includes the towns of Mafikeng, Lichtenburg and Zeerust. The area has a population of about 1m and Moyo believes its customer base could be as high as 100 000 people within five years.
The company plans to create a core GSM network within the next 12 months. It will also build a high-speed data network, probably using WiMax, a new wide-area wireless networking technology. It will use this data network to offer broadband Internet access. He believes there is a pent-up demand, as Telkom does not offer its broadband digital subscriber lines in the region.
Moyo hopes Karabotel will launch in the first week in June. Its counterpart in the northwestern Free State district of Lejweleputswa, Welkom-based B-Tel, also plans to launch next month. CEO Dominic Mokheti says B-Tel will initially piggyback on Vodacom’s network but plans an aggressive expansion of its own infrastructure, too.
It is seeking up to R250m in funding to build a network to serve the area’s population of more than 800 000. Mokheti says the business opportunity is in the voice market, but it will offer Internet access, too.
Reproduced with the permission of the Financial Mail
Original article: http://secure.financialmail.co.za/05/0513/technology/atech.htm