“Unclear, vague and confusing”
This is the common thread weaving through the comments made by MTN, Cell C, the Internet Society of SA and the Online Publishers Association (OPA) on the bill, which is in its third draft form and was released on February 16. Written comments on the bill had to be submitted by April 8, leading to some parties lamenting that there was insufficient time to compile a thorough response to the draft bill.
There have also been concerns about the independence and maintenance of transparency of the industry’s regulator, Icasa, as well as definition of roles between the regulator and the competition commission. The bill proposes the communications minister be able to issue policy direction without consulting with the regulator.
These issues have been a key feature in the oral presentations made to the parliamentary portfolio committee on communications (PPCC) thus far, with Icasa chairman Mandla Langa and Zodwa Mbuli, compliance manager at the competition commission, both addressing the committee on Tuesday. Hearings on the bill are expected to be held on Tuesdays and Fridays “for the next few months”, Dene Smuts – who represents the Democratic Alliance (DA) on the committee – told Moneyweb last week.
MTN states that although the bill is “an improvement from the previous DOC draft bill, numerous contradictions omissions and ambiguities remain”, which “create a document that is difficult to interpret and impossible to implement, thus leaving the draft legislation open to various conflicting interpretations.”
Where’s the policy to guide the legislation?
Both MTN and Cell C said that the absence of the white and green paper formulation process has been detrimental because there is a lack of consensus about what exactly convergence is, with Cell C saying that government’s vision with respect to convergence policy and legislation is not clear. Indeed, Cell C points out that convergence has not been defined in the bill, “nor is there a common understanding that when promulgated, the bill will provide for its achievement.”
MTN says the enactment of the bill should be delayed “pending the development of clear policy objectives through a green and white paper process”.
What’s in a licence definition?
A concern expressed in all submissions reviewed is that there are many imprecise definitions in the bill, and that some are inconsistent with those provided in the 12 other acts (including amendment acts) which govern broadcasting and telecommunications (although the new act will replace five of these acts, all pertaining to telecoms and broadcasting). MTN calls the content “unclear, vague and confusing”, and attributes this to the “absence of a clear licensing structure for a converged industry.”
Both the OPA and the Internet Society say the definitions of application and content services and providers – if retained in their current form – would result in “adverse consequences” as any person or organisation placing content on the internet – including, for example, “guesthouses which market their accommodation and services online, corporate newsletters, state libraries, anyone who has a website, and all newspapers who publish online” – would need a licence to “publish”.
States the Internet Society ominously: “The requirement to license these entities, even at no cost to the licence holder, is seen as an unnecessary barrier to entry and has a chilling effect on the sector with the resultant loss of jobs and unenforceable law.”
The broad strokes approach taken in the bill, together with the absence of a step-by-step outline of the transition from the current to proposed frameworks, says MTN, mean the bill “is likely to achieve the exact opposite of its stated objects, namely to encourage investment in the communications sector, and to safeguard the economic fabric of South Africa.”
Original article: http://www.moneyweb.co.za/news/tech_stocks/443812.htm